mon 15/07/2024

Europe: Them or Us, BBC Two | reviews, news & interviews

Europe: Them or Us, BBC Two

Europe: Them or Us, BBC Two

Nick Robinson tiptoes cautiously through the minefield of Britain's relations with Europe

Gravy train? Euro-leaders assemble for another jolly (on expenses)

The BBC opened its examination of the history of European togetherness with presenter Nick Robinson beaming at us from the top of those White Cliffs, looking out at the glistening sea which made us an island (until, of course, Mrs Thatcher supported the Channel Tunnel).

This inconclusive history of Britain in and out of Europe began at the very end of the Second World War, when the eloquent proposer of a united Europe which definitely included West Germany was Sir Winston Churchill. This first episode of two, subtitled "An Island Apart", set the scene with two ex-politicians, Hague and Blair, commenting how different Britain is from Europe, while surprising vintage film showed the great wartime leader visiting Amsterdam post-war where he was serenaded by thousands singing a new song, "Europe United". We were also reminded that in 1940, just before France was invaded, Churchill’s war cabinet backed the audacious proposal to unite France and Britain in terms of both defence and economy, although foundering on the notion of a single currency. ("Non!" Charles de Gaulle, pictured below).

It started with an ideal; by uniting across the continent there would be no more war. Robinson led us through the various landmarks: the 1951 European Steel and Coal Community of West Germany and France, ECSC, later joined by Benelux (remember Benelux?) and Italy, the small print hinting at a federal Europe to come. Clips with the grand old men, no longer with us, reminiscing on the events of 1950 and onward included knights galore, diplomats and politicians, from Douglas Jay to Frank Roberts and Roger Makins. At a crucial cabinet meeting senior members were away, and Britain was given an ultimatum to ratify or not; with no decision, the ultimatum passed. The rules of the European club to be were made by the founder members.

March 1957 brought the Treaty of Rome, and the European Economic Community, with the original six nations, with Britain still not playing. Helmut Schmidt abstained from voting on the treaty, as he was distressed that Britain was not part of the deal. The British Prime Minister, Harold Macmillan, was hostile: he felt that Western Europe, dominated by West Germany, gave the Germans on a plate everything that Britain had fought two world wars to prevent. The continent, we were told, yearned for British leadership, but Britain was still outside. And Macmillan did a U-turn, perhaps on the basis of "if you can’t beat them, join them". Enter Edward Heath, the master of detail, negotiating for months in Brussels ("Oui!" Ted Heath, pictured below).

The road to union remained treacherous and surprising in its twists and turns. We witnessed the Labour leader Hugh Gaitskell leading the charge that Britain was just not part of Europe; Europe’s borders were at the Rhine, Britain reached to the Himalayas, and we would be abandoning 1,000 years of history to cosy up to the continent. Roy Jenkins, in a marvellous smoothy-chops clip, described how even over lunch at the Garrick Club he could not persuade Gaitskell to change his mind.

January 1963, and cue the huge press conference in Paris, with 800 journalists, when de Gaulle clearly said "Non" to his erstwhile close colleague Harold Macmillan, spelling out in his terms that Britain was maritime and insular. Macmillan was distressed to the point of tears. France had effectively blackballed Britain, which evidently made Britain desperate to join the club that had so unexpectedly closed its door.    

Heath it was who refuted every point the French made, and it was Pompidou and Heath who finally brought about the rapprochement, literally fuelled by gastronomic diplomacy. The great lunch in Paris took place at the British embassy under the skilled supervision of the British ambassador, Christopher Soames, not only Churchill’s son-in-law but a cheerful and clever bon viveur. One French politician indicated that doing business with the Americans would be impossible because of the lack of American culinary skill, but this luncheon did the trick. Meanwhile British fishermen protested by going up river to show that they were being sold down the river.

Heath was accused of betraying Britain and we were shown the extraordinary secret machinations, masterminded by Francis Pym, and recorded by a backbench MP in a big red book, by which Labour pro-Europeans supported the Tory government (which had only a small majority) to vote in favour of Europe. Enoch Powell demonstrated in measured speech his fury in his classical rhetorical style; the anti-European Tony Benn (pictured above) said, in a spasm of barely controlled anger, that the vote for Europe in Parliament was in fact a coup d'état

There was a neat caricature of Harold Wilson sitting on the fence, but Episode One ended in 1975 with a referendum under Labour, and Britain no longer out but in. Heath turned out to be a master: the act before Parliament was a mere dozen clauses, and was whipped through, when the anti-Europeans had expected a thousand at least, and therefore years of delaying debate.

The music was properly portentous. The producer John Bridcut was also responsible for the 1996 BBC programmes on the EU, entitled The Poisoned Chalice – there's BBC impartiality for you – whence many of the interviews with those who have now passed on were taken. Next week’s episode is subtitled "Voice of the People".

The road to union remained treacherous and surprising in its twists and turns


Editor Rating: 
Average: 3 (1 vote)

Share this article

Add comment

Subscribe to

Thank you for continuing to read our work on For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 15,000 pieces, we're asking for £5 per month or £40 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.

To take a subscription now simply click here.

And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a gift subscription?


Get a weekly digest of our critical highlights in your inbox each Thursday!

Simply enter your email address in the box below

View previous newsletters