thu 18/08/2022

Music Reissues Weekly: The Sun Shines Here - The Roots Of Indie-Pop 1980-1984 | reviews, news & interviews

Music Reissues Weekly: The Sun Shines Here - The Roots Of Indie-Pop 1980-1984

Music Reissues Weekly: The Sun Shines Here - The Roots Of Indie-Pop 1980-1984

A great listen, but despite this box set’s title a definition of ‘indie-pop’ remains out of reach

Altered Images, caught outside the W. Fenn shop along Soho’s Frith Street. Were they ‘indie-pop’?

The Sun Shines Here - The Roots Of Indie-Pop 1980-1984 is three-CD set in a clamshell box with 74 tracks. The opener is “Better Scream”, January 1980’s debut single from Wah Heat!

The closing track was issued in November 1984: The Jesus And Mary Chain’s first single “Upside Down”. In between: Mo-Dettes, The Monochrome Set, Microdisney and Marine Girls. Lori & The Chameleons, Ludus, The Loft and The Lines too. There’re also the pre-fame Pulp, Prefab Sprout, Hurrah! and lesser-knowns like Junes Brides offshoot The Ringing and The Page Boys, who spawned 1000 Violins.

The Sun Shines Here is the follow-up to the 2013 five-disc set Scared To Get Happy (which dealt with 1980 to 1989). When this column looked at Scared To Get Happy, it was noted that “the musical styles covered are diffuse” and that “the nature of indie is partly in the eye of the beholder.” The same comments apply to the more trim but still whopping The Sun Shines Here. While it is a great listen, digs deep and has a broad perspective, it is impossible to get close to what “indie-pop” is.

The Sun Shines Here The Roots Of Indie Pop (1980-1984)A well-known web site has an entry for “indie-pop”. The opening paragraph ties itself in knots. With this set, beyond saying “the tracks on this compilation, just like those on (the 1982 compilation album) Pillows & Prayers, illustrate the vibrancy and the diversity of the music that coalesced into indie-pop,” The Sun Shines Here sidesteps semantic banana skins by otherwise ignoring them. However, it is hard to see what Sixties band The Misunderstood, Kevin Coyne and Quentin Crisp – who were on Pillows & Prayers – have to do with indie-pop.

Looseness is endemic in the world of The Sun Shines Here. The use of The Jesus And Mary Chain track as the cut-off isn’t explained in the accompanying booklet’s introductory essay and track-by-track commentary. Similarly, the reason for choosing Wah Heat! as the kick-off isn’t given. This elusiveness does not make what’s collected deficient. But it is hard to see how some of the tracks qualify beyond having an independent-minded sensibility. Disc One includes “Insects” by Altered Images.The B-side of their hit single ‘I Could be Happy”, it was issued by Epic. Great, but is it indie-pop? It's pop, but it is not independent. The same applies to Aztec Camera’s “Jump”, a WEA B-side. Borderline inclusions come from Manicured Noise and Scars, both of whom were on an imprint backed by a major label.

The booklet’s introductory essay sets out the path to this blurriness by outlining an accepted inspirational sequence: Buzzcocks's Spiral Scratch EP, then the Desperate Bicycles and early Scritti Politti. These bands booked the studio, paid for it themselves and put out their own records on their own labels. They did it all themselves and were integral to fomenting the punk/post-punk do-it-yourself outlook. As an umbrella, independent can encapsulate DIY but when a band issues a record on a label not run by themselves the relevance of this foundational trio diminishes.

The Sun Shines Here - The Roots Of Indie Pop 1980-1984_manicured noiseAlthough nothing is said in the booklet to explain The Sun Shines Here’s date range, the first formal independent chart was published in January 1980 – around the time of the set’s earliest tracks. Spizzenergi’s “Where's Captain Kirk?” occupied the top spot. The Dead Kennedys, Delta 5, The Monochrome Set and Scritti Politti were in there too. The last two are on The Sun Shines Here. Fiddler's Dram’s “Day Trip to Bangor” was at number two. This chart was about independent distribution not musical styles; the lack of involvement with a corporate infrastructure was needed to qualify for inclusion. A reissue of Black Sabbath’s “Paranoid” was a Number One independent single in summer 1980. The way the independent charts were compiled meant they were a stylistically broad church. Looking at them is unhelpful to defining indie-pop.

At the other end of The Sun Shines Here’s time line, The Jesus And Mary Chain would – unwittingly – help shift indie to become a label which did not necessarily mean independent. When they signed to a label funded by Warners, the Mary Chain’s spirit may have been the same for a while but they helped construct the foundations for indie as a meaningless / woolly tag. By mixing major label releases with the barely issued, The Sun Shines Here shows that corporates were messing with what might be seen as indie in 1981 or 1982.

The Sun Shines Here - The Roots Of Indie-Pop 1980-1984 is, on the face of it, a pretty straightforward canter through a period when idiosyncratic bands who realised their pop sensibility might give them a chance at the mainstream existed alongside (albeit wonderful) commercial no-hopers. But what’s not said matters too. And that includes a definition of indie-pop.


Add comment


Get a weekly digest of our critical highlights in your inbox each Thursday!

Simply enter your email address in the box below

View previous newsletters