tue 11/05/2021

Requiem, BBC One review – everything but the scares | reviews, news & interviews

Requiem, BBC One review – everything but the scares

Requiem, BBC One review – everything but the scares

New horror series hits familiar notes, but struggles to leave a mark

Lydia Wilson stars as Matilda Grey: concert cellist turned ghost hunterBBC/New Pictures/Todd Antony

Despite horror’s omnipresence in cinema, British television has been somewhat deprived of jump scares.

Despite horror’s omnipresence in cinema, British television has been somewhat deprived of jump scares. Every couple of years there’s an anomaly, such as Sky’s The Enfield Haunting or ITV’s Marchlands, but nothing has caught the public’s imagination – not since the innovative but controversial one-off Ghostwatch. Enter the BBC and Netflix with their new six-part series Requiem, promising to be the most terrifying show ever broadcast on the Beeb.

Either the worst is yet to come, or the terror bar has been set very low; episode one brought little innovation and even less tension. There were the obligatory bangs in the night, interference on the radio, mysterious deaths, but nothing to nudge the heartbeat above resting.

The haunting scenes are too brief, with little incident or imagination

We were introduced to Matilda Grey (Lydia Wilson), your average twenty-something hipster cellist, who passes her days swiping Tinder and headlining concert halls. After a last-minute brunch with her lonely and obsessive mother Janice (Joanna Scanlan, pictured below), she popped to soundcheck for her big opening night. But poor mum was paid a visit by the static ghost that skips your CD and makes you commit suicide. After a creepy but PG sequence involving a kitchen knife, Matilda was left traumatised and motherless.

Soon, Matilda and her accompanist Hal (Joel Fry) were on the road to rural Wales, looking for answers after finding a box filled with old news clippings about a missing girl. However, the village is coming to terms with its own mysterious suicide, and now Matilda’s shacking up in a spooky yet familiar mansion.

There’s a fine art to a terrifying ghost story, evident from The Haunting (1963) to The Conjuring (2013): take time to invest in the characters; extend sequences to build tension; and ration out the jump scares. These rules are all linked to the pacing of the story, and Requiem is a perfect example of why they struggle to translate to television; episode one has an hour to introduce the concepts, engage the viewer, offer some genuine thrills, and keep enough back for five more episodes. The horror staples appear incompatible with television viewing – the characters feel underdeveloped and the tension flatlines.Joanna Scanlan in RequiemThe haunting scenes are too brief, with little incident or imagination. A knock here, a stereo detune there, it’s all a bit pedestrian. Just when it looks like we’re about to see something chilling, it cuts to the next scene. There’s an air of menace around the following suicides, but nothing to keep you up at night.

That’s not to say that there are no signs of promise. The cast is uniformly excellent, with lead Lydia Wilson finding a solemn determination in Matilda. There is also a genuinely interesting mystery among all the ghostly bumps – what went down in 1994 before Carys Howells went missing?

Requiem sets its stall firmly in supernatural territory; there’s little comedy, and the script falls into exposition too easily to compete with high-end drama. The only problem is: it’s not really scary. But with everything established, maybe it can now settle into providing some real chills. The whole series is now available on BBC iPlayer – perhaps give one more episode the chance to sink its claws into you.


The characters feel underdeveloped and the tension flatlines


Editor Rating: 
Average: 3 (1 vote)

Share this article


Great loved it but the ending four graves not five, is there going to be more than this series?

That's six hours of my life I'll never get back. The ending was silly. Plain silly. I stuck with it because I had hopes. Oh well.

Lots of long atmosphrtic sceens with nothing happening, could have been done in 4 episodes. Predictive plot so no suspence or horror value. right up to the rather silly ending.

Doesn't seem remotely scary to me - too much Hitchcock style plagiarism ( birds, showers etc.) . Not a patch on Trauma on ITV - now that has real tension and drama.

Very silly all the way through. The most spooky part was the self cleaning blue coat- where can you buy one of those?

Overindulgence, trying to encapsulate too many genres & overuse of special effects tried to compensate a weak storyline. A promising start rapidly disintegrated into mediocrity because a Welsh-based drama tried morphing with Shetland & Merrily Watkins. Keep it simples!

Complete trash. Please do not go to season 2.

Add comment


Get a weekly digest of our critical highlights in your inbox each Thursday!

Simply enter your email address in the box below

View previous newsletters