Help keep arts journalism alive.

We’re rebuilding theartsdesk to secure it as a bastion of real culture writing in the face of algorithmic recommendations and AI slop. Your participation is absolutely vital to this - subscribe today and be part of this movement.

SUBSCRIBE TODAY 

4.48 Psychosis, Royal Opera, Lyric Hammersmith review - despairing truth in song and speech

Philip Venables' opera is now as classic as the Sarah Kane drama it sets

share this article

Utterly convincing: Gweneth-Ann Rand and Susanna Hurrell in 4.48 Psychosis
Stephen Cummiskey

Depression, with or without psychotic episodes, is a rare subject for drama or music theatre - and with good reason: the sheer unrelenting monotony of anguish and self-absorption is hard to reproduce within a concentrated time-span. So we still stand in awe of Sarah Kane for the way she managed, months before her suicide, to wring from the depths and write in blood such a kaleidoscopic range of despair and black vision in 4.48 Psychosis; in awe, too, of composer Philip Venables, for finding an equal variety, and an even greater eclecticism, in the musical voices to tell a drama of pain that is anything but general.

This, its first revival since 2016, proves that it's one of only two new or recent works produced under Kasper Holten's Royal Opera aegis - the other is Gerald Barry's The Importance of Being Earnest - that's here to stay.

Masterpiece or not, 4.48 Psychosis the opera is a very rare case of the music reflecting what could be an overpowering text at every point. Kane's words by themselves will always be the richer option because of their total authenticity, even in the occasional bathos and banality. Some of Venables' sequences sound a bit more generic - the slow-burn meshing of his six female voices, for instance, brilliant idea though it was to have them represent aspects of the undoubted protagonist, sufferer, patient, call her what you will - the utterly convincing Gweneth-Ann Rand (pictured above), as before. Others add a layer to Kane's writing and can be hair-raising, not least the fast passages involving numbers and lists; difficult to catch all the amplified words here when they're not flashed up as text on the back wall, but the fizzing textures are the thing, with bending string lines and shrieking woodwind (flute/piccolo and three saxophones), Birtwistle-style, from the hard-working CHROMA under Richard Baker.

CHROMA in 4.48 Psychosis

The visionary hour around 4.48am inspires music for a black-and-white mass. Most riveting of all is the dialogue between (we assume) patient and psychiatrist which launches the work - as a monologue since one of the two remains silent - and is, perhaps, its only developmental strand. CHROMA's two percussionists, Louise Goodwin (pictured above), beat out the speech-rhythms on bass drum and other hard-hitting instruments against dribbling recorded muzak while the text is seen below. It's as if the protagonist is under water in her isolation, and barely hearing properly; towards the end, mezzo Lucy Schaufer begins to articulate the psychiatrist's words. It's moving; there is professional help here, but the main character (Kane, surely) is beyond it.

It's not always easy to work out who's singing what; given the non-directional miking and the darker lighting in D.M. Wood's palette on Hannah Clark's set, but Susanna Hurrell excels as a more companionable self and there's fine ensemble work from newcomers to the production - I presume, since the characters' names seem to be those of the original singers - Lucy Hall, Samantha Price and Rachel Lloyd. Director Ted Huffman overcomes the problem of a specific location for a totally unspecific text - a room with a glass door, table and chairs - by drawing variety parallel to Kane and Venables from his team and video designer Pierre Martin. Not easy listening and watching, then, but decidedly a confirmation of a classic.

The music reflects what could be an overpowering text at every point

rating

4

explore topics

share this article

more opera

Puccini's 'Turandot' and Verdi's 'Aida' work in Italy's third largest Roman colosseum
Zurich Opera production has some good singing, but its mood is monochrome
Singers, and players, rise above some clunky moments in Strauss's meta-opera
Missy Mazzoli’s impressive new opera follows Wynton Marsalis' jazz symphony opening night
Michael Gallen's riveting music-theatre piece has committed performances all round
Architecture, balance and charm in the David McVicar production
Laurent Pelly's production proves you can have a great cast yet fail them as characters
A magnificent cast manages to master Gerald Barry's Wilde and act their crazy socks off
Two tales of magic and mystery - as TV reality show and environmental parable
Quality take on Verdi and a pure comedy re-imagining of Léhar
Turbocharged orchestra, sometimes too much so, various approaches from the singers