fri 08/12/2023
Home > node > Exile, BBC One

Exile, BBC One | reviews, news & interviews

Exile, BBC One

Exile, BBC One

John Simm and Jim Broadbent brilliantly paired in dark North Country thriller

by Wednesday, 04 May 2011
Share
Unreliable memories: John Simm as Tom (left), Jim Broadbent as Sam

In a week unfeasibly packed with new drama across the BBC and ITV, the three-part Exile may prove to be the one that lingers longest. It was a thriller and a detective story, but what gave it its formidable grip was the way the central mystery was intricately entwined with the painful personal story of  Tom Ronstadt (John Simm) and his father Sam (Jim Broadbent).

In a week unfeasibly packed with new drama across the BBC and ITV, the three-part Exile may prove to be the one that lingers longest. It was a thriller and a detective story, but what gave it its formidable grip was the way the central mystery was intricately entwined with the painful personal story of  Tom Ronstadt (John Simm) and his father Sam (Jim Broadbent).

The idea of Alzheimer's disease as a metaphor for the unbearable stresses of the past wasn't laboured, but the relationship between father and son was movingly drawn

Buy

Explore topics

Share this article

Share

Comments

Submitted by Elaine (not verified) on Wed, 04/05/2011 - 10:52
Exile was simply brilliant, no other word for it. I was gripped from start to finish (and in tears by the end). If this doesn't win awards (most notably for John Simm who has never been properly recognised in the Gong Department) then there is no justice. And if Danny Brocklehurst should decide to novelise this, I for one would buy it like a shot. Excellent. Now, when's the DVD out??

Submitted by Sue Kenyon (not verified) on Wed, 04/05/2011 - 11:18
I agree this was most compelling television drama. All actors were brilliant and particulary John Simms whose career I have always followed since the Lakes. Definitely an award contender. The story made you want to now more about these characters and John simms watching the video from his father was EXCELLENT!

Submitted by David Mawdesley (not verified) on Wed, 04/05/2011 - 12:33
I can't believe that someone might think this programme was compelling viewing. In my opinion the plot was weak, the guilt of the councillor not made clear - what did he do? Was there the slightest piece of evidence that he conspired in the numerous rapes? Surely one is not expected to believe the police would act as they did on the instructions of a tin pot council leader in a tiny Lancashire village! Come on, give us some credit! What on earth did the pregnancy of the son's sister have to do with anything? I agree that the performance of the actors was excellent but this did not make the three consecutive nights worth viewing ( or the licence money)

Submitted by dramafan (not verified) on Wed, 04/05/2011 - 22:38
A song can be personal, drama can be personal, which means different people can read different things from the same lyrics / section / segment. "What on earth did the pregnancy of the son's sister have to do with anything?" To me it was part of a subplot around the sister, and all that she had given up to be a carer. Is is unfair that she ends up missing out on her best years, and settling for the boring guy who bonks her, on the first night off she's had in ages? Probably. You may have read this completely differently, but no matter. The music I thought played a big part - anyone know who did the music? - tried google but nothing I could find there.

Submitted by MikeP (not verified) on Fri, 06/05/2011 - 13:40
Like David Mawdesley I felt the plotting around Metzler was weak, and the idea that he could run somewhere like Oldham (not exactly a village!) as his private fiefdom with the fuzz at his beck and call didn't hold up. Unlike David Mawdesley, however, I didn't care, because the performances were so fantastic, especially Jim Broadbent's, who just gets better and better. We were glued to the screen for 3 hours - excellent use of licence payers' money!

Submitted by Jane (not verified) on Sat, 07/05/2011 - 10:07
Have just watched this on IPlayer after it was recommended by a work colleague and i thorougly enjoyed it, so refreshing to see a decent drama on the tv rather than all these reality and talent shows

Submitted by Claire Hamilton (not verified) on Sat, 07/05/2011 - 22:23
I've just watched all 3 episodes on iplayer, and throughly enjoyed it! Outstanding performances, from John Sims and Jim Broadbent in particular. I found the use of humour via the outlet of Alzheimer's Disease completely endearing. All involved have done a superb job in highlighting the tragedy surrounding Alzheimer's in an empathetic manner. Well done to all involved.

Add comment

more TV

Kin, BBC One review - in Dublin's not-so-fair city Superb cast and powerful writing fuel this gripping gangland drama
Boat Story, BBC One review - once upon a time in Yorkshire New Williams brothers thriller is violent, far-fetched and extremely watchable
The Crown, Season 6, Netflix review - royal epic in a vain search for authenticity It looks like news photos coming to life, but the dialogue and concept still jar
Brawn: The Impossible Formula 1 Story, Disney+ review - classic underdog tale of the little team that could Inside story of Jenson Button's amazing championship year
Shakespeare: Rise of a Genius, BBC Two review - the Bard's soul bared in hybrid drama-documentary Speculation and facts woven into a compelling portrait of a singular man
Shetland, Series 8, BBC One review - same place but a different programme DI Ruth Calder faces an uphill struggle to replace DI Jimmy Perez
Robbie Williams, Netflix review - tormented superstar bares his soul Gruelling rockumentary explores the price of fame
Fellow Travellers, Paramount+ review - four-decade saga of power, politics and gay love Plush TV treatment of Thomas Mallon's bestselling novel
The Pigeon Tunnel: Stories from the Life of John le Carré, Apple TV+ review - outstanding, intriguing portrait of David Cornwell Errol Morris's film puts the author in a hall of mirrors where the truth is satisfyingly elusive
Frasier, Paramount+ review - he's back! But should he be? Can Kelsey Grammer and a new cast make lightning strike again?
The Reckoning, BBC One review - Savile saga that doesn't tell the whole story The BBC’s finely acted docudrama is too little, too late
Reckoning with the Jimmy Savile legacy - Steve Coogan stars in BBC One's four-part 'factual drama' Is Savile's career of evil suitable for prime-time entertainment?

newsletter

Get a weekly digest of our critical highlights in your inbox each Thursday!

Simply enter your email address in the box below

View previous newsletters