sat 20/07/2024

Bach B minor Mass, Trinity College Choir, OAE, Layton, St John's Smith Square | reviews, news & interviews

Bach B minor Mass, Trinity College Choir, OAE, Layton, St John's Smith Square

Bach B minor Mass, Trinity College Choir, OAE, Layton, St John's Smith Square

Choral and trumpeter angels from the realms of glory in Bach's panoply of invention

The Choir of Trinity College Cambridge and Stephen Layton 'at home'Keith Saunders

While the embers of the concert year are dying out around the country, you can be sure of a great blaze-up at St John’s Smith Square. The annual Christmas Festival of quality early-music groups and top choirs – this is the 29th – now traditionally culminates in two great works for chorus and orchestra.

Over the past three years I’ve reeled at the best of Messiahs, four cantatas out of the six making up Bach’s Christmas Oratorio – and now that God of music’s ultimate demonstration of his omnipotent range.

The B minor Mass may seem even less seasonal than two-thirds of Messiah, but it has its equal share of angels from the realms of glory, with David Blackadder (pictured below in one of the Orchestra of the Age of Enlightenment's publicity campaigns, fun but don't blame the trumpeter) playing Gabriel as archangel of the trumpet trio and producing silvery yet piercing sounds from what by now should be the irreplaceable period instrument in these works. Then there’s the chorus. I doubt if, even with previous near-perfection from the choirs of The Sixteen and Clare College, I’ve ever heard more focused brilliance in Bach’s insanely florid runs than from the 40-something voices in the Choir of Trinity College, Cambridge.

David BlackadderTrue, the evening didn’t get off to a perfect start, with the briefest moment of mud from the men in the opening chords of the Kyrie and a tempo bump from conductor Stephen Layton in the first duet. But it could rarely be faulted after that, with OAE strings instilling absolute ease and confidence.

The quality of three of the soloists, Christmas Festival regulars, one could take for granted: soprano Katherine Watson and Neal Davies, more baritone than bass, are lightish but supremely musical singers, Davies shining more in the poise of “Et in spiritum sanctum” than in “Quoniam tu solus”, which seems to have been written for a lower range (and also had the drawback of Roger Montgomery, usually a peerless player, finding difficulty with his horn in the obbligato). Iestyn Davies was flawless as ever, each year seeming to find more lights and colours in the countertenor voice than I used to think possible; 2014 has been exceptional for him even by his own highest standards. New on the scene was tenor Gwilym Bowen, still at the Royal Academy of Music and yet to relax on the platform – that's understandable enough – but a promising and agile voice even so.

I teared up at the three usual points, though hearing different emphases. Though I grew up with the Karajan recording of the B minor Mass, and James Galway, then Berlin Philharmonic principal, peerless in the flute duet and solo, the more haunting sound of the period-instrument equivalent produced greater wonders here in the expressive adornment to the choir’s infinitely expressive “Qui tollis”. In fact the subtlest wonder of this performance was how instrumental lines always shone through even with the choir in richest form, from Lisa Beznosiuk on the top line here to Chi-chi Nwanoku’s incisive doubling of the basses’ descent in the Sanctus – which, of course, has to be the tears-for-joy passage in excelsis; I’m glad Layton swung the heavenly hammer at a spacious pace, where the tendency is too often to rush. And the final “Dona nobis pacem” was the serious seal on the entire masterpiece, rising to a sumptuousness one wouldn’t have thought possible in St John’s – and a last climb above the sopranos’ line from Blackadder.


I'm pretty sure that picture of David is from about 4 years ago now. Hardly the 'latest'. Should probably check that, artsdesk.

No better ones to be found, Chris, unless you can point me in the right direction in which case I'm happy to replace. But I'll revise the text accordingly, thanks for pointing it out (of course I should have remembered that the latest OAE publicity is one with banners).

I found the choir took a while to wake up and get going. The start was 'muddy', but the balance of the sopranos, being divided into 1st & 2nd, was insufficiently strong to balance the remainder of the parts, especially through the Kyrie fugues. It was not until the Gloria did the choir's energy and brilliance show through, and there it remained for the rest of the performance. The counter tenor, mezzo, and bass were exemplary, engaging with their accompanying continuo, and one cannot help but give the highest praise to the flute solos and duet accompaniments, with a wonderful light touch, sensitive phrasing and dynamic, which were then mirrored skilfully by the strings. The young and energetic choir responded extremely well to the Layton treatment - detached semi-quaver runs, and delivering some beautiful phrasing and dynamic for which Layton is a master. Sanctus and Pleni were fabulous, from both choir and orchestra, and the relatively tame Dona Nobis was a sensitive and perfect ending to a great overall performance.

Add comment

Subscribe to

Thank you for continuing to read our work on For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 15,000 pieces, we're asking for £5 per month or £40 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.

To take a subscription now simply click here.

And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a gift subscription?


Get a weekly digest of our critical highlights in your inbox each Thursday!

Simply enter your email address in the box below

View previous newsletters