thu 30/05/2024

Dalgliesh, Channel 5 review - doleful detective fails to fire on all cylinders | reviews, news & interviews

Dalgliesh, Channel 5 review - doleful detective fails to fire on all cylinders

Dalgliesh, Channel 5 review - doleful detective fails to fire on all cylinders

Bertie Carvel's Adam Dalgliesh is decent but dull

Soporific? Bertie Carvel as Adam Dalgliesh

Treading in the footsteps of Roy Marsden and Martin Shaw, Bertie Carvel is a making a decent (albeit soporific) stab at embodying P D James’s introspective detective Adam Dalgliesh, though you have to wonder if he’s getting the help he needs from Channel 5.

This current series of three two-part stories over consecutive nights is designed to grab two bites of the audience cherry, but would surely have greater impact and more narrative coherence as three two-hour slots. It never did Poirot or Morse any harm.

The problem is the commercial TV hour, which gets you about 47 minutes of programme after you take out the ads and bits of network blurb. It leaves you out of pocket if you’re trying to create atmosphere, build characters and knit it all together with a dark and mysterious plot, with the result that everything seems to have been speeded up and had chunks chopped out.

In last week’s tale, Shroud for a Nightingale, we barely had any idea who Dalgliesh was before he was gruffly barking detective-style questions at the inmates of a nurses’ training school, eventually leading to the frankly unfeasible unmasking of a mass-murdering former Nazi nurse. In this second story, The Black Tower, he was more reminiscent of a mendicant monk than a senior detective from the Metropolitan Police, as he lamented the death of his old spiritual counsellor Father Michael at Toynton Grange, a spooky home for the disabled on an expanse of rugged Dorset coastline. Then again, Dalgliesh’s father was a cleric in Norfolk, so I suppose he has some excuse (below, one of this lot probably did it).The device of the enclosed, isolated society with evil lurking within can be a powerful one (as James’s readers will know), but while Dalgliesh is beautifully photographed in sumptuous locations and does a nice line in baleful, melancholy background music, these curious outposts peopled with a selection of sinister eccentrics can rapidly begin to seem self-parodic. We first met the angry and aggressive Victor Holroyd, though not for long, since he was swiftly despatched from a steepling clifftop in his wheelchair. Steven Mackintosh played Wilfred Antsey, a wild-haired fanatic in a monk’s habit who ran Toynton’s annual pilgrimages to Lourdes, and his lust for control soon put him in the frame as a potential killer, but as the bodies piled up – next came poor old 83-year-old Grace and then feisty Maggie Hewson, all adding up to a healthy percentage of Toynton’s complement of guests – the spotlight gradually swung away from him.

Various infidelities, betrayals and disappointments hinted at possible motives, though the dreary litany of the Toynton “guests” lamenting their lack of communication, their inability to come to the aid of poor Maggie who’d apparently committed suicide (but hadn’t, obviously), and the general all-round misery and woe did make you wish somebody would come along and cart them all off to Butlin’s for the day.

The denouement was as sudden as it was preposterous, as if The French Connection had suddenly descended upon darkest Dorset, though it was startling to see the cerebral and usually motionless Dalgliesh involved in a savage punch-up with a chap called Marsh. Carvel is doing his best to depict a lonely man who has known bereavement and disillusion (even his desirable E-Type Jaguar doesn’t seem to bring him much cheer), but so far Dalgliesh is failing to fire on all cylinders.

It made you wish somebody would come along and cart them all off to Butlin’s for the day


Editor Rating: 
Average: 2 (1 vote)

Share this article


The adaptations are a abysmally hackded down version of the original P D James brilliant stories. The previous versions with Roy Marsden were excellent and also 4-1/2 hours long in 3 parts whereas this new disaster is a mere 1-1/2 hours and have also altered the plots and the personalities of major characters. Such a disappointment.

Loved this show. Very little grabs my attention on television these last few years. But I have seen other actors play the role and each have added a bit of themselves to the character of Adam Dalgliesh all of whom I have enjoyed watching. If there is a problem it is with channel 5. It is not long enough, cut the adverts down, and run the series for longer. I have enjoyed watching Bertie Carvel in this role and hope that we will see more of him as Adam Dalgliesh.

Have to disagree. I thought Bertie Carvel was a magnificent Dalgliesh!

Thought it was beautifully written. Love Bertie in this role. Never fancied Shaw in it (but really rated him as George Gently. ) Too short though!

I gave up halfway through The Black Tower I'm afraid. Carvel is not a patch on Roy Marsden, the plots have been mucked about with, and the whole thing has about as much life and character as month-old lettuce.

There is no way in the world that Adam Dalgliesh would say GARRIDGE instead of gar-age

Add comment

Subscribe to

Thank you for continuing to read our work on For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 15,000 pieces, we're asking for £5 per month or £40 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.

To take a subscription now simply click here.

And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a gift subscription?


Get a weekly digest of our critical highlights in your inbox each Thursday!

Simply enter your email address in the box below

View previous newsletters