sun 16/06/2024

BBC Philharmonic, Wellber, Bridgewater Hall, Manchester review - new conductor’s debut | reviews, news & interviews

BBC Philharmonic, Wellber, Bridgewater Hall, Manchester review - new conductor’s debut

BBC Philharmonic, Wellber, Bridgewater Hall, Manchester review - new conductor’s debut

Harbinger of things to come – the spirit of the stage

Omer Meir Wellber - brisk and informalBBC Philharmonic

Two days after announcing his appointment as their next chief conductor (he takes the reins officially next summer, in time for the Proms), by remarkable good fortune the Manchester-based BBC Philharmonic was able to present Omer Meir Wellber as the conductor of their second Bridgewater Hall series concert.

It was a harbinger of things to come – he said as much in the talk before the concert – in that he’s an experienced opera conductor and wants to bring the spirit of the stage, and probably the reality of more operatic performances, to the Philharmonic’s programming.

So his Mozart opener – the "Linz" Symphony, No. 36 – was confessedly there as a kind of overture to the hour of Wagner (Act 1 of Die Walküre) which followed. It was a pretty good curtain-raiser on his BBC Phil era, and the "flexibility" he talked about in his pre-concert interview with BBC Philharmonic general manager Simon Webb was soon to be seen and heard. He strode on to the platform in lounge suit and open collar, gave a brisk bow, and we were off. This was Mozart done by an expert. He’s economic of gesture, flexibility itself in body language, and had the measure of the hall acoustic immediately as the 31-strings orchestra (guest led by George Tudorache) played with telling precision and transparent tone.

The sound of his BBC Philharmonic was gentle, restrained even, yet the operatic touch was there from the start: the introduction was played with bated breath and effective contrasts, and the allegro built energetically after an innocuously undemonstrative entrance. But there were soloistic moments for the woodwind and mystery every now and then, while melody led the texture all the way. The presto finale was like it: another whispered beginning, smoothness and a sense of line amid the scuttering string writing, and fun creeping in with a touch of exaggeration right at the end. But the inside movements raised more questions than answers. The triple-time andante was quite stately, sometimes almost hesitant, and for all its precision and delicacy was on the edge of mannerism; the Minuet took another leisurely pace and came over as rather too studied for its own good.

Christiane LiborOn to Wagner, though, and now we had the full forces of the Phil, the strings almost doubled in number. Wellber had the benefit of three outstanding soloists for the story of Sieglinde and Siegmund’s dawning affection (never mind that they’re twins – it’s a gigantic love duet). Christiane Libor (pictured right) has a glorious, young but full soprano sound and an excellent Wagnerian track record; Robert Dean Smith is a seasoned Heldentenor, unflinchingly strong – and Brindley Sherratt, as Hunding, brought the note of pent-up violence and menace.

I expect it was the orchestra’s combined resources and splendour of tone that also impressed many of the enthusiastic crowd. The same qualities of attention to articulation and vivid contrast that we’d heard in the Mozart were now painted on a much bigger, broader canvas. Wellber said before he began that for him as an Israeli it’s Wagner’s greatness as a composer that he honours, not his wacky philosophies, and he knows where the jewels lie in the vast cave of this score. We heard remarkable warmth in the string playing in the first encounter of the two young protagonists, incisive brass playing as the warlike themes for Hunding emerge, and wonderfully mellow trombone tone in the aural echoes of Das Rheingold’s Valhalla.

Wellber paced the piece superbly, bringing vivid qualities to the accompaniment of Siegmund’s story of his battle and mounting tension and a great crescendo as the two men faced off against each other. Then there was a slow build-up of excitement and exultation as the twins discovered each other in the moonlight, their passionate love music building to a resplendent brass-led chorus as Siegmund drew the magic sword – and a big finish. It was quite a series debut.

Subscribe to

Thank you for continuing to read our work on For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 15,000 pieces, we're asking for £5 per month or £40 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.

To take a subscription now simply click here.

And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a gift subscription?


Get a weekly digest of our critical highlights in your inbox each Thursday!

Simply enter your email address in the box below

View previous newsletters