Film: Paranormal Activity | reviews, news & interviews
Film: Paranormal Activity
Film: Paranormal Activity
Heart-stopping terror-fest or whole lotta hype?
Monday, 23 November 2009
Demonic interference was ruining poor Katie's complexion
Low-budget horror movie, comprising supposedly "found" video footage depicting freaky supernatural events... it's Blair Witch 2!
Indeed, writer/director Oren Peli has taken discount film-making to new extremes, using his own home in San Diego as his sole location, restricting the cast to five (I can't even remember the "Girl on Internet" mentioned in the cast list), and bringing the piece home for a ridiculous $15,000.
Thanks to some cunning marketing, including special midnight screenings (so spooky!) and some viral internet action, Paranormal Activity's earnings have already breached the $100m threshold. And the bad news? It's not very good.
At least Peli can't be accused of needlessly over-complicating the plot. When young middle-class couple Katie (Katie Featherston) and Micah (Micah Sloat) move into a new home, they find themselves discomfited by strange noises in the night. Micah buys himself a video camera to capture evidence of whatever it is making those weird creaks and bangs. Things go from bad to worse. End of. Actually Peli does introduce one innovation to the hyper-cheap genre, by keeping the camera static at the foot of the couple's bed to record what happens while they're asleep. At least those portions of footage are free from the motion-sickness jitter that made, for instance, the lo-fi monster movie Cloverfield barely watchable (another wild night for Katie and Micah, below)
Elsewhere, Peli sticks slavishly to the simplest principles. The tension barely seems to ratchet up at all for the first 45 minutes, then gradually the unseen demon becomes grouchier and more menacing. The bedroom door slams instead of merely moving a couple of inches. When Mica sprinkles powder on the floor, the Thing obligingly leaves what look like cloven hoofprints. After something unseen grabs Katie's leg and drags her out of bed, the going gets rough.
Perversely, it seems to be the sheer predictability of the story that audiences are responding to, as if ritual given a superficial re-spray can easily trump innovation. The crowd I saw it with reacted to each episode of creepiness with theatrical screams, exclamations of shock or nervous laughter, and psychologists would doubtless tell us that the frisson of shared peril taps into our most primitive instincts.
But horror movies frequently depend on the idiocy of the protagonists, and in order to make the narrative stretch to 85 minutes, Peli has had to make Micah an Olympic-class bonehead. Katie's increasingly panicky warnings that he's provoking the demon by perpetually filming it go unheeded, and his response to the supernatural terror is a sort of chippy petulance. Even when It begins to display ominous destructive potential, for instance by slashing his photograph on the wall, Micah still runs around the house shouting at it in farcical displays of college-jock bravado.
In fact analysis is best avoided, since a minimum of rational thought (in daylight of course) exposes gaping fissures in Paranormal's architecture. Despite the mounting sense of threat, Micah and Katie make barely any effort to help themselves (most people would have tried moving out of the house, though of course that's difficult when there's no budget for additional locations). They do call in a psychic (Mark Fredrichs), but his sole role in the drama is to say "hey, this is really bad, you'll have to call a real demonologist" before fleeing through the front door. And as for the central notion of the video recordings of the sleeping couple, nobody could possibly have got a wink of sleep with such an uncouth and malevolent interloper in the house.
There were plans to remake Paranormal Activity as a big-budget major release, but Peli must be doing cartwheels of joy that they weren't realised. If the film had been deprived of its low-rent underdog status, there wouldn't have been a lot left to recommend it.
- Paranormal Activity is on general release from 25 November
Subscribe to theartsdesk.com
Thank you for continuing to read our work on theartsdesk.com. For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 15,000 pieces, we're asking for £5 per month or £40 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.
To take a subscription now simply click here.
And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a theartsdesk.com gift subscription?
more Film
Twisters review - satisfyingly cataclysmic storm-chaser saga
It's like 1996's 'Twister', except it goes up to 11
The Echo review - a beautiful but confusing look at life in a Mexican village
A docufiction captures the prescribed lives of rural Mexican girls and women
About Dry Grasses review - warts and all portrait of an unhappy man
Nuri Bilge Ceylan delivers a compelling chamber piece on an epic scale
In a Violent Nature review - inverted slasher is fascinating
Told entirely from a masked killer's perspective, this experiment is confident and strange
Crossing review - a richly human journey of discovery
Levan Akin offers a masterfully observational perspective on Georgian, Turkish worlds
Janet Planet review - teasing dissection of a mother-daughter relationship
Annie Baker impressively transfers her subtle theatrical skills to the screen
Chuck Chuck Baby review - love among the feathers
Louise Brealey and Annabel Scholey shine in a working-class musical romance
More Than One Story review - nine helpings of provocative political theatre
Cardboard Citizens shine an unforgiving light on poverty in the UK
Longlegs review - like its titular killer, this summer's most hyped horror film leaves no trace
A white-knuckle experience, but not much more, despite Nicolas Cage on familiar form
Sleep review - things that go bump in the night
Weird nocturnal phenomena threaten couple's marital bliss
Fly Me to the Moon review - NASA gets a Madison Avenue makeover
How politics and propaganda drove America's race into space
MaXXXine review - a bloody star is born
Mia Goth's horror final girl goes to Eighties Hollywood in Ti West's trashy, sly sequel
Add comment