Swan Lake, English National Ballet, Coliseum

The Agony is worth it for the Ecstasy of a splendid company show

by Judith FlandersWednesday, 23 March 2011

ENB's 'Swan Lake' corps: Photographed by their leading ballerina Daria KlimentováDaria Klimentová

As everyone who has been watching Agony & Ecstasy: A Year with the English National Ballet on BBC Four now knows, Vadim Muntagirov, last night’s Prince Siegfried, and Daria Klimentová, his Odette/Odile, are the ultimate in ballet melodrama: one is a young dancer on the rise, the other reaching the end of a notable career. And both came together to produce a memorable Swan Lake in Derek Deane’s tasteful proscenium production.

Swan Lake is Lev Ivanov’s compelling take on the heat of Romanticism, channelled through a prism of icy cold Classicism

Buy

Find Swan Lake on Amazon

Explore topics

Share this article

...

Permalink Submitted by J.Brand (not verified) on Thu, 24/03/2011 - 14:48

Judith Flanders should know that Tchaikovsky never composed a waltz for Act 1V. The one referred to is an interpolation of a movement from his Piano Pieces op.72 crassly orchestrated by Riccardo Drigo and endlessly repeated thus destroying its original charming character. The score of Swan Lake is a minefield of cutting, transposing, reordering of movements and interpolations in most choreographic interpretations. Check with David Nice! Strangely enough the only version I know which sticks to Tchaikovsky exactly in the last act is Matthew Bourne's version.

...

Permalink Submitted by David Nice on Thu, 24/03/2011 - 15:35

But I think, to confuse matters still further, Judith means the very Russian Danse des Petites Cygnes, which fits into the Act 4 tragedy beautifully, is one of the highlights of the score and isn't a waltz. So does that mean that this production, like the Mariinsky Sergeyev staging, actually replaces it with that dramatically inert waltz-plum? I ask because I'd be quite happy to see this, but not if Act 4 isn't all of a piece - the musical substitution is too banal. And it's not as if the original isn't the shortest and most unified act in ballet.

Add comment

more Dance

Cinderella, Royal Ballet review - the first British ballet learns the language of flowers Plant life blooms everywhere you look in Frederick Ashton's earliest full-evening ballet

Tom Dale Company, The Place review - immersive and genre-busting Dazzling, ingenious, thought provoking - a big thumbs-up to the digital revolution

'You want to cry from loving to do it so much' - Lynn Seymour 1939-2023 Remembering the unique ballerina who injected me with her poison

Turn It Out with Tiler Peck, Sadler's Wells review - America's ballet wonder-woman raises the barre On her UK solo debut, New York City Ballet’s queen of speed gives audiences a wild ride

Woolf Works, Royal Ballet review - Wayne McGregor's modern classic impresses all over again Alessandra Ferri returns as the moving focus of this powerful piece

The Sacrifice, Dada Masilo, Brighton Dome review - eye-popping dance from South Africa The dance is riveting but the story is murky

Creature review - Asif Kapadia shines light on a dark dance piece The ballet has been transformed by a film version that gets up close and personal

Julie Cunningham & Co, Sadler's Wells review - a fine piece of work, with added spice The other Cunningham stakes out their territory in contemporary dance, and the non-binary debate

Swan Lake, English National Ballet, Coliseum review - the story of a deluded prince The corps de ballet take the laurels in Derek Deane's dependably fine production

Best of 2022: Dance It might not be business as usual, but memorable work has come through

Matthew Bourne's Sleeping Beauty, Sadler's Wells review - a gothic romance with loads of goth and not much love Revival of Bourne's vampire ballet drives a stake through the heart of Beauty

Ruination, Linbury Theatre review - Medea gets a makeover Ben Duke and Lost Dog inject fresh life - and some laughs - to the grisliest of Greek tragedies

Follow @theartsdesk