Scottish Chamber Orchestra, Ticciati, Usher Hall, Edinburgh

Three racy French scores overshadow Kevin Volans's new journey to nowhere

by David NiceSaturday, 28 August 2010

Robin Ticciati: Line and life in three French scoresChris Christodoulou

Which of the following has the thorniest dissonance: an early 18th-century dance-drama by Rebel, a symphony by Bizet, a concerto by Poulenc or a new work by South African composer Kevin Volans? If you think it's a trick question, you'll guess the right answer: the earliest. And which of the four sounds the least fresh and novel? My own take on that is the most recent.

A few baleful woodwind chords apart, the progress of Volans's CSS Alabama is without compelling ideas

Explore topics

Share this article

more Classical music

Natalie Dessay, Philippe Cassard, Milton Court review - flashes of magic More downtime than expected in an intelligent programme

Paul Lewis, Wigmore Hall review - Schubert sonatas revisited A meditation on how the pianist handles what he calls 'inconsequentiality'

Voces8 Foundation Choir and Orchestra, Smith, Voces8 Centre review - joyous Christmas music by Bach Seasonal greatest hits selection with a spotlight on spectacular trumpeting

First Person: Natalia Franklin Pierce, Executive Director of Nonclassical, on 'creating a sense of belonging' On bringing classical music to wider audiences - and appealing for help in a good cause

Grosvenor, Park, Ridout, Soltani, Wigmore Hall review - chamber music supergroup in perfect accord Thoughtful programming puts quirky novelty alongside big beasts

Dariescu, BBC Philharmonic, Storgårds, Bridgewater Hall, Manchester review - sounds of unquenchable optimism Conductor is his own violin soloist in one of two UK premieres

MacMillan's Christmas Oratorio, Lois, Williams, RSNO, MacMillan, Usher Hall, Edinburgh – a great composer at the top of his game Scottish premiere of a recent masterwork

Louise Alder & Friends, Wigmore Hall review - magic carpet rides with soprano, strings and woodwind Levitational joy in an all-French programme, with modified rapture over two arrangements

Aurora Orchestra, Kings Place review - experimental work in an immersive setting A conceptually elegant evening that transported you to a different dimension

Morison, Immler, BBCSO, Bychkov, Barbican review - a Kafka journey and a mighty landmark Multi-tasking maestro shines with new songs and old forms

Classical CDs: Microphones, mazurkas and mad scenes Piano concertos, operatic intermezzi and a striking collection of songs

Grosvenor, SCO, Emelyanychev, Usher Hall, Edinburgh review - lightness of touch and a sprinkling of humour Romantic music played with period style, and the pianist finds the wit in Mendelssohn

Follow @theartsdesk