The Headless Woman | reviews, news & interviews
The Headless Woman
The Headless Woman
Hitchcock channelled in a briliant and baffling psychothriller from Argentina
Saturday, 20 February 2010
A merciless anatomy of the inner meltdown that follows a hit-and-run accident, The Headless Woman is as baffling, brilliant, demanding and utterly original a work as you're likely to see all year. Its themes are confusion, amnesia, disavowal. The director, Lucrecia Martel, by contrast is in vice-like control of her material. This film might be a real head-scratcher. But no-one seeing it can come out unconvinced that Martel is a world-class talent.
It is set in Northern Argentina, the location of the director's two previous features, La Ciénaga (The Swamp) and The Holy Girl. Verónica, Vero for short, is an elegant middle-aged, middle-class woman who, driving home one day, fast, is briefly distracted by her mobile phone. There is a mighty thud. She stops. Takes a moment to collect herself. Looks in the rear-view mirror where a vague shape is visible: it must be a dog, or else a stone on the road. And continues on her way. Before the collision, we'd briefly glimpsed a cluster of urchins playing at the roadside. A small boy is found dead later, not at the scene of the accident, but not all that far away either.
Suspecting concussion, Vero goes to hospital for a brain scan. It is inconclusive. But henceforth nothing in her life appears to make sense. Her husband, her lover and extended family proceed as though nothing were wrong, rolling up the car windows and switching on the air-con (both literally and metaphorically) to shut out the stench of death. Something indefinable is out of kilter.
In one sense Martel is channelling Hitchcock in her theme of a lone woman caught up in a paranoid conspiracy - there's even Hitch's trademark trope, as seen in Vertigo and Marnie, of the blonde who turns herself into a brunette at a pivotal moment. The camera fetishises Veronica's tangle of yellow curls (see the original poster, left), just as Hitchcock kept plunging into Kim Novak's chignon coil in Vertigo. It's a sort of post-modern tribute to the Master.
But attention must be paid: you won't find the answers to this mystery handed out on a plate. Characters appear without being introduced in accordance with the conventions of Screenwriting 101. On occasion their heads are, appropriately, cut off by the frame. The film is shot in CinemaScope, but the director doesn't favour the usual big tableaux. Close-ups dominate and an extremely shallow focus keeps the background at bay, as seen in the still, top (which has been cropped slightly from the side for technical reasons).
There are few establishing shots. So off-kilter is the composition of the images that sometimes, as in the still below, you're unsure how to decipher them. There is a suite of narrative ruptures and disconnects, as though the film's own very synapses had been damaged in the collision. It's the expression, in formal terms, of Vero's confusion and anxiety.
Yet, though apparently told from her viewpoint, the story keeps distant from its main character. Vero is strikingly blank and brittle. While not unkind, she leads a shuttered life in which servants and indigenous people are blurry ghosts at the edges of the frame, scarcely noticed (María Onetto's precise performance treads the fine line between making you involved with her, while not really liking her). Her repression of the accident is, according to Martel in an excellent long interview in Film Comment magazine, part and parcel of a greater collective act of national forgetting.
"I see people that still carry the weight of the really bad stuff that they did not denounce back when it happened under the dictatorship," the director said there. "A lot of people decided they didn't want to see, they didn't want to know what was happening. And now the same process is occurring, but it's in relation to poverty." She believes that, far from being an open, unreadable text, The Headless Woman is crystal-clear. Many viewers will disagree and it's certain that the film would richly reward a second viewing.
While the subject is entirely rooted in Argentina, its enigmatic and contemplative tone has more in common with Michael Haneke than with recent work to emerge out of Latin America or with Pedro Almodóvar, who co-produced the movie. In Cannes two years ago, The Headless Woman was roundly booed and has taken nearly two years to reach Britain, thanks to the good offices of New Wave Films, a small distributor whose name is virtually a kitemark for discerning art cinema, But it is playing on just one screen in London, and at a scattering of regional locations, and so no time should be wasted in catching it.
The Headless Woman is on release now.
Suspecting concussion, Vero goes to hospital for a brain scan. It is inconclusive. But henceforth nothing in her life appears to make sense. Her husband, her lover and extended family proceed as though nothing were wrong, rolling up the car windows and switching on the air-con (both literally and metaphorically) to shut out the stench of death. Something indefinable is out of kilter.
In one sense Martel is channelling Hitchcock in her theme of a lone woman caught up in a paranoid conspiracy - there's even Hitch's trademark trope, as seen in Vertigo and Marnie, of the blonde who turns herself into a brunette at a pivotal moment. The camera fetishises Veronica's tangle of yellow curls (see the original poster, left), just as Hitchcock kept plunging into Kim Novak's chignon coil in Vertigo. It's a sort of post-modern tribute to the Master.
But attention must be paid: you won't find the answers to this mystery handed out on a plate. Characters appear without being introduced in accordance with the conventions of Screenwriting 101. On occasion their heads are, appropriately, cut off by the frame. The film is shot in CinemaScope, but the director doesn't favour the usual big tableaux. Close-ups dominate and an extremely shallow focus keeps the background at bay, as seen in the still, top (which has been cropped slightly from the side for technical reasons).
There are few establishing shots. So off-kilter is the composition of the images that sometimes, as in the still below, you're unsure how to decipher them. There is a suite of narrative ruptures and disconnects, as though the film's own very synapses had been damaged in the collision. It's the expression, in formal terms, of Vero's confusion and anxiety.
Yet, though apparently told from her viewpoint, the story keeps distant from its main character. Vero is strikingly blank and brittle. While not unkind, she leads a shuttered life in which servants and indigenous people are blurry ghosts at the edges of the frame, scarcely noticed (María Onetto's precise performance treads the fine line between making you involved with her, while not really liking her). Her repression of the accident is, according to Martel in an excellent long interview in Film Comment magazine, part and parcel of a greater collective act of national forgetting.
"I see people that still carry the weight of the really bad stuff that they did not denounce back when it happened under the dictatorship," the director said there. "A lot of people decided they didn't want to see, they didn't want to know what was happening. And now the same process is occurring, but it's in relation to poverty." She believes that, far from being an open, unreadable text, The Headless Woman is crystal-clear. Many viewers will disagree and it's certain that the film would richly reward a second viewing.
While the subject is entirely rooted in Argentina, its enigmatic and contemplative tone has more in common with Michael Haneke than with recent work to emerge out of Latin America or with Pedro Almodóvar, who co-produced the movie. In Cannes two years ago, The Headless Woman was roundly booed and has taken nearly two years to reach Britain, thanks to the good offices of New Wave Films, a small distributor whose name is virtually a kitemark for discerning art cinema, But it is playing on just one screen in London, and at a scattering of regional locations, and so no time should be wasted in catching it.
The Headless Woman is on release now.
more Film
Love Lies Bleeding review - a pumped-up neo-noir
There's darkness on the edge of town in Rose Glass's sweaty, violent New Queer gem
Nezouh review - seeking magic in a war
A movie that looks on the dreamier side of Syrian strife
Blu-ray: The Dreamers
Bertolucci revisits May '68 via intoxicated, transgressive sex, lit up by the debuting Eva Green
theartsdesk Q&A: Marco Bellocchio - the last maestro
Italian cinema's vigorous grand old man discusses Kidnapped, conversion, anarchy and faith in cinema
I.S.S. review - sci-fi with a sting in the tail
The imperilled space station isn't the worst place to be
That They May Face The Rising Sun review - lyrical adaptation of John McGahern's novel
Pat Collins extracts the magic of country life in the west of Ireland in his third feature film
Stephen review - a breathtakingly good first feature by a multi-media artist
Melanie Manchot's debut is strikingly intelligent and compelling
DVD/Blu-Ray: Priscilla
The disc extras smartly contextualise Sofia Coppola's eighth feature
Fantastic Machine review - photography's story from one camera to 45 billion
Love it or hate it, the photographic image has ensnared us all
All You Need Is Death review - a future folk horror classic
Irish folkies seek a cursed ancient song in Paul Duane's impressive fiction debut
If Only I Could Hibernate review - kids in grinding poverty in Ulaanbaatar
Mongolian director Zoljargal Purevdash's compelling debut
The Book of Clarence review - larky jaunt through biblical epic territory
LaKeith Stanfield is impressively watchable as the Messiah's near-neighbour
Add comment