fri 28/02/2020

Room at the Top, BBC Four | reviews, news & interviews

Room at the Top, BBC Four

Room at the Top, BBC Four

John Braine's 1957 novel about sex and social ambition still rings true

On the up: Matthew McNulty as Joe Lampton in Room at the Top

Do we really needed to hear more from Joe Lampton, the anti-hero of John Braine’s Room at the Top? His battle for social advancement and sexual self-expression has long since stopped holding up a mirror to society, you'd think. In fact we nearly didn’t hear more from him in this new BBC adaptation. Anyone turning on BBC Four one night in April last year expecting to watch would have been disappointed. Owing to a late-blooming rights dispute, the BBC decided on the day of broadcast not to go ahead. Now, 18 months later, with all legal ducks finally in a row, the first episode went out last night.

Braine's debut remains his most widely read and best remembered novel. It was lassooed into that loose formation of agitating works by the so-called Angry Young Men. The hopes for self-betterment of his young accountant on the make embodied those of an entire generation: having contributed to the war effort, they were now gagging for a piece of the action. That meant climbing the social ladder, and having lashings of sex on the way up. Two years after publication the book became even better known for Jack Clayton's screen version. Laurence Harvey as Braine’s working-class protagonist got an Oscar nomination despite a northern accent that came via Lithuania and South Africa. As his married lover Alice, it famously featured the even more exotically miscast Franco-German Simone Signoret.

The BBC’s version is by Amanda Coe (previously responsible for TV biopics of Elizabeth David and Mary Whitehouse) and directed by Aisling Walsh (Wallander, Fingersmith). It was clear within five minutes that this visit to the 1940s was very frankly simmering with sexual tension. Seams were practically bursting, flies popping as Matthew McNulty’s Joe arrived in a northern mill town to take up his new job. He was soon eyeing up the swivelling rumps of his secretarial co-workers and receiving smouldering glances from the amdram soc’s hot-to-trot thespians. One local temptress was first in the queue to give him a good old-fashioned thus-far-but-no-further teasing. His groin thus baited, Joe chose to ignore the mismatch between his sexual ambitions and his earning potential and set his sights on prim young industrialist's daughter Susan Brown (Jenna-Louise Coleman). He partly fancied her, partly her lofty social position.

But a deeper empathy was soon sprouting between him and Maxine Peake’s Alice Aisgill, older by a decade and childlessly married to a cold-hearted car dealer (Peake pictured above right, and left with McNulty). After a lonely Christmas (his parents were killed in the war) they embarked on their liaison. There was a beautiful scene in her car, snow billowing outside, cigarette smoke and steam fogging the windows. His need to be mothered was somehow mirrored by her need for rugged worship. “Don’t fall in love with me,” she advised postcoitally, only to be soon hosting trysts in a borrowed flat. No sooner consummated than the affair foundered on his – in her word – “provincial” line in retrospective jealousy and working-class rage. Step forward once more, Susan Brown. By the end of the first episode Joe had seen off her Cambridge-educated, officer-class beau and her suspicious father (Kevin McNally), and seduced her in the stairwell.

The fumbled, stolen sex looks like a grim postcard from a sepia-stained yesteryear when no one got any how's your father. And yet this craftily adapted and truthfully performed Room at the Top still has something instructive to say. An atmospheric visit to a moment in our history when society was in a state of anxious flux, it tells of the demobbed Lamptons clambering up the greasy pole because, for the first time ever, they could. Now that social mobility has ground more or less to a halt, the story of Braine's ambitious lothario reads like a prescient rebuke from a bygone age.

Follow Jasper Rees on Twitter

It was clear within five minutes that this visit to the 1940s was very frankly simmering with sexual tension

Share this article

Comments

Outstanding cast, true to 1948 rather than the late 1950s, which locates it properly, it exudes a kind of provincial authenticity and delivers some great scenes.

I watched both episodes of this serial with interest.The acting was unsurpassed,particularly Matthew McNulty,a thoroughly unpleasant Joe Lampton.Alice,played by Maxine Peake,offered us an insightful portrayal of a deeply unhappy woman.The only part that spoiled it for me was when she retaliated to Joe after he confessed that he was engaged to another woman. Alice spoke vulgarly and graphically about what he had done to her sexually,thus reverting to 21st Centuryspeak and almost crushing the authentic post WW2 ambience of the story. That aside,I found Room At The Top to be powerful,direct and with a strong moral message. Thank you for this review.

Add comment

Subscribe to theartsdesk.com

Thank you for continuing to read our work on theartsdesk.com. For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 10,000 pieces, we're asking for £3.95 per month or £30 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.

To take an annual subscription now simply click here.

And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a theartsdesk.com gift subscription?

newsletter

Get a weekly digest of our critical highlights in your inbox each Thursday!

Simply enter your email address in the box below

View previous newsletters