mon 04/12/2023
Home > tv > Midsomer Murders, ITV1

Midsomer Murders, ITV1 | reviews, news & interviews

Midsomer Murders, ITV1

Midsomer Murders, ITV1

Neil Dudgeon is the new DCI Barnaby in suddenly controversial show

by Wednesday, 23 March 2011
Share
Neil Dudgeon as DCI John Barnaby, with a rather desirable MGA sports car

It'll be interesting to see what the recent race row - or more accurately, lack-of-race row - does for the ratings of Midsomer Murders. Possibly nothing, if the research that says that people from ethnic groups all hate the show and never watch it is to be believed. It certainly defies logic that producer Brian True-May has been made to walk the plank for saying that the programme has an all-white cast when... it does. Somehow, everybody has contrived not to mention this ever since Midsomer began in 1997.

It'll be interesting to see what the recent race row - or more accurately, lack-of-race row - does for the ratings of Midsomer Murders. Possibly nothing, if the research that says that people from ethnic groups all hate the show and never watch it is to be believed. It certainly defies logic that producer Brian True-May has been made to walk the plank for saying that the programme has an all-white cast when... it does. Somehow, everybody has contrived not to mention this ever since Midsomer began in 1997.

An epidemic of improbability had infested Darnley Park girls school, like mice in the wainscoting

Buy

Explore topics

Share this article

Share

Comments

Submitted by Roger Neill (not verified) on Thu, 24/03/2011 - 08:37
It does seem to me that we Brits are in favour of freedom of speech so long as it doesn't inconvenience us. The way footballers and their managers are treated is more suitable to the Soviet Union in its prime. Perhaps a new Gulag could be set up in the Highlands for those who step out of line.

Submitted by Julia (not verified) on Thu, 24/03/2011 - 20:33
I thought it was perfectly dreadful. I was trying to find something I recognised. Causton, the sleepy little market town had transmogrified into bustling Windsor? What was all that about? Neil Dudgeon, whom I normally admire as an actor, was dreary though it was hardly his fault due to the awful script. but he's got a long way to go to match the charisma of John Nettles. Forget Midsomer. It was just another cop show and a not very good one at that. If I hadn't know that Brian True-May was still involved I would have thought he had already departed. I should think he is well shot of it if the first episode was anything to go by.

Submitted by Margaret Eccles (not verified) on Thu, 31/03/2011 - 17:27
I actually switched to another channel after the first 10 minutes or so - first time ever! However, I gave it another chance with last night's second episode - much better! Almost credible...... And I really like Neil Dudgeon as Tom's cousin (think I prefer him to the sainted Nettles....)

Add comment

more TV

Boat Story, BBC One review - once upon a time in Yorkshire New Williams brothers thriller is violent, far-fetched and extremely watchable
The Crown, Season 6, Netflix review - royal epic in a vain search for authenticity It looks like news photos coming to life, but the dialogue and concept still jar
Brawn: The Impossible Formula 1 Story, Disney+ review - classic underdog tale of the little team that could Inside story of Jenson Button's amazing championship year
Shakespeare: Rise of a Genius, BBC Two review - the Bard's soul bared in hybrid drama-documentary Speculation and facts woven into a compelling portrait of a singular man
Shetland, Series 8, BBC One review - same place but a different programme DI Ruth Calder faces an uphill struggle to replace DI Jimmy Perez
Robbie Williams, Netflix review - tormented superstar bares his soul Gruelling rockumentary explores the price of fame
Fellow Travellers, Paramount+ review - four-decade saga of power, politics and gay love Plush TV treatment of Thomas Mallon's bestselling novel
The Pigeon Tunnel: Stories from the Life of John le Carré, Apple TV+ review - outstanding, intriguing portrait of David Cornwell Errol Morris's film puts the author in a hall of mirrors where the truth is satisfyingly elusive
Frasier, Paramount+ review - he's back! But should he be? Can Kelsey Grammer and a new cast make lightning strike again?
The Reckoning, BBC One review - Savile saga that doesn't tell the whole story The BBC’s finely acted docudrama is too little, too late
Reckoning with the Jimmy Savile legacy - Steve Coogan stars in BBC One's four-part 'factual drama' Is Savile's career of evil suitable for prime-time entertainment?
Boiling Point, BBC One review - chef drama that's simmering nicely Terrific drama series has been whipped up from Stephen Graham's hit film

newsletter

Get a weekly digest of our critical highlights in your inbox each Thursday!

Simply enter your email address in the box below

View previous newsletters