sun 16/06/2024

Mayday, BBC One | reviews, news & interviews

Mayday, BBC One

Mayday, BBC One

Nightly rural mystery features the strange case of a Midsomer Killing

Copper couple: Peter McDonald and Sophie Okonedo in 'Mayday'

A drama that opens with the disappearance in the woods of a beautiful blonde teenage girl is going to evoke memories of Nanna Birk Larsen racing away from her murderer in The Killing. A drama set in a rural English village peopled by loamy eccentrics and sozzled toffs is likely to summon thoughts of Midsomer Murders. Put ‘em together and what have you got?

Mayday is working a nightly hourlong shift across the week. This is an occasional style of scheduling that works well so long as the story grabs the viewer by the throat and refuses to slacken its hold. Five Daughters, about the murder of five sex workers in Ipswich, took on a kind of propulsive force. Top Boy, featuring criminal gangs in Hackney, gripped like a vice. Five Days, on the other hand, felt like five weeks. And one has a twitchy feeling about Mayday. March when it starts, at this rate it may well feel like the eponymous May when it ends later this week.

So far we have been introduced to a teeming cast, although we don’t yet have a body. A case of habeas corpus (non). Nor do we even have much of a copper. Sophie Okonedo plays a constable who has long since left the force to look after her young brood. We can expect her detecting instincts to kick in soon – indeed she already smells a rat at the alarming antics of her husband (Peter McDonald), who’s also a bobby.

And so it goes for the rest of the village. Those acting oddly are precisely counterweighted by those who find their behaviour a bit fishy. Peter Firth gets sloshed in his loft while working on a model of the village, venturing out to the woods to “walk the dog”, actually to decorate a pagan den deep in the forest discovered by his nervy wife (Lesley Manville). Then there’s Aiden Gillen’s thoroughly shady ducker-and-diver, who won’t tell his teenage son what’s in the large bag he’s stashed in the locked cupboard. Indeed, the village sports the usual array of creeps, foaming weirdos and wide-eyed loons, often lurking in trees (pictured above right, for example). Plus the odd floppy-fringed teenager.

The concept behind the script by Ben Court and Caroline Ip is that a terrible crime in a tight community brings out in the innocent the instinct both to suspect and suppress. It’s a neat idea for spinning out the mystery. The snag is that this sort of thing is rather more intriguing when located in Scandinavia than in Sussex. A hallucinatory opening promises woozy stylistic trickery. The shortly-to-be-abducted May queen cycles through the village to meet her appointment with the Mayday float, as figures in the parade loom before her like scary denizens of the pre-Christian occult. Then Mayday settles down into a supermarket whodunwot full of actors who look as they couldn’t pick a Friesian out of a line-up of zebras.

  • Mayday is on BBC One at 9pm until Thursday
This sort of thing is rather more intriguing when located in Scandinavia than in Sussex


Editor Rating: 
Average: 2 (1 vote)

Explore topics

Share this article


May day is a cry for help and I certainly think that the person who wrote this needs it!!!!!!!!!!!!

Quite liked it - some of the story did not quite seem to hang together. Rather sort of upmarket Midsomer Murders - also probably an episode too long.

Couldn't agree more. First Poliakoff's onanistic epic, Dancing On The Edge. Now this crass and overlong take on Midsomer Murders. Painful to watch (for all the wrong reasons) and a waste of talent and time. Such a shame...

Thought this was absolutely hilarious! The thing that kept me just about from losing the will to live was the characters themselves - what a hoot!

Endless scenes of people walking up and down looking shiftily towards the camera, with nothing much ever happening. On and on and on. I hung on until the bitter end thinking it would all be worth it. It wasn't. A ridiculous plot, full of non sequiturs and inconsequentialities, a waste of Peter Firth's talent (was he that desperate for the dosh?) and a totally implausible finish. The BBC needs to take a look at the drama ITV has been airing to see where it has to improve.

Started well....ended appallingly! Really began to question the acting ability of some of the cast....really could not work out what the stay at home policewoman was trying to convey, she came across as a real wodden top! I love a good crime drama, this wasn't in that calibre. I actually feel embarrassed that this was shown on the Beeb....not up to their high standards.

I really liked this program, held on the edge of my seat for five days. Admittedly could get a little long but found the ending breathtaking.

Staggeringly bad

Ambitious, watchable, didn't pull it off. ...'couldn’t pick a Friesian out of a line-up of zebras' - don't do that again Jasper.

Add comment

Subscribe to

Thank you for continuing to read our work on For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 15,000 pieces, we're asking for £5 per month or £40 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.

To take a subscription now simply click here.

And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a gift subscription?


Get a weekly digest of our critical highlights in your inbox each Thursday!

Simply enter your email address in the box below

View previous newsletters