Cloud Atlas | Film reviews, news & interviews
Star company assumes various guises as David Mitchell's time-travelling masterpiece is lovingly told in under three hours
Skipping across time and place – South Pacific 1849 to Cambridge/Edinburgh 1936 to San Francisco 1973 to UK (looks like England) 2012 to Neo Seoul 2144 to Earth’s post-apocalyptic Hawaii 2321 – Cloud Atlas is like a scary old punk who's actually quite nice. A simple and satisfying moral centre stops you from feeling its 172 minutes are a waste of time and its six stories don’t intertwine as much as play tag with each other. But look past extraordinary makeup, special effects, distracting painted horses and Hugo Weaving as Old Georgie, an irritating amalgam of Tom Waits and Johnny Depp, and you’ll get it. You'll understand that it's okay to ask, "Isn't that Tom Hanks?"
Based on David Mitchell’s 2004 novel, Cloud Atlas has been lovingly and independently produced by The Matrix siblings Lana and Andy Wachowski and Tom Tykwer. Halle Berry, Tom Hanks, Hugo Weaving, Jim Sturgess, Susan Sarandon, Hugh Grant, Ben Whishaw (pictured below) and Doona Bae pop up in various guises as different creeds and sexes throughout six main storylines about what matters most: giving a damn.
Hanks plays Zach'ry, a futuristic/throwback goatherd who speaks pidgin English, an Irish author with a terrible Irish accent and a false friend onboard a sailing ship in the 19th century, among other roles – and that’s part of Cloud Atlas’s fun: not only is it about love across dimensions but also about identifying famous actors beneath makeup, wigs and wardrobe. As the needle of the story plunges in and out of the fabric of time, the audience plays Who's This? with the cast. Even if the quality of its acting varies hugely, for the most part, Cloud Atlas stays focused and accessible. Bae and Jim Broadbent anchor its emotional pivots. Robert Fyfe playing Mr Meeks and David Gyasi as Autua are beautiful performances that cannot fail to delight.
So is the film like the book? Well, because film and books are two different media, hard as that may be to grasp for some, it would be folly to expect any film to be “just like the book”. Like Naked Lunch, The Sheltering Sky, Heart of Darkness, The Road and many others, Cloud Atlas was considered to be unfilmable. However, like The Life of Pi which finally came to the big screen in 2012 as well, "unfilmable" can be wrested by expert editing into a form suitable for film. Here, the Wachowski siblings and Tykwer keep the book’s essence by making the stories alternate rather than occur each inside the other. A larger emphasis on a variety of love relationships and recognisable actors playing multiple roles (some more successfully than others) allow the source material to breathe again. The comet-shaped birthmark is still there, as are other beloved tropes.
Criticised for many things, among them its use of "yellow-face", i.e. white actors playing Asias, the film’s fanbase has seen beyond that, suggesting Cloud Atlas could attain cult status like Aronofsky’s The Fountain. Although yet to make a profit, this is a daring film that strives to achieve the impossible in Hollywood: genuine sincerity.
Subscribe to theartsdesk.com
Thank you for continuing to read our work on theartsdesk.com. For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 10,000 pieces, we're asking for £2.95 per month or £25 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.
To take an annual subscription now simply click here.
And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a theartsdesk.com gift subscription?
Jesse Eisenberg and Kristen Stewart take on the CIA in a geeky action caper
Rousing Randolph Scott Western with a semblance of truth
Allusive meditation on creativity from banned Iranian director Jafar Panahi
theartsdesk recommends the half-dozen top movies out now
Vivid documentary on resistance to Mexico's drug cartels hits home
Jessica Chastain and Colin Farrell are the mistress and servant messing with each other’s heads in an airless Strindberg adaptation
Carey Mulligan sparkles but Thomas Vinterberg's Hardy is only a partial account
Charlotte Rampling and Tom Courtenay shine in Andrew Haigh's wintry marital drama
Arch reimagining of a gruesome 1976 proto-slasher film of the same name
Finely formed tale of battling the odds from the director of 'The Page Turner'
Uneven TV travelogue from the maverick director
James Franco nears rock bottom in London-set thriller