DVD: When I Saw You

This heartfelt Palestinian drama is a poetic look at one kid’s journey of displacement

share this article

Mahmoud Asfa plays Tarek, a boy in pursuit of an imagined freedom

Like its title, this film is surprisingly open in its capacity for possibility. It's ironic that this blossoming branch – When I Saw You – is set in the stilted habitat of a refugee camp in Jordan. It’s a sweet film that gets to the heart of the Palestinian conflict, cinematically as well as through its characters.

The year is 1967, the Six-day war has just happened and 11-year-old Tarek (Mahmoud Asfa, pictured below) is fast realising his stay in Harir with his mother Ghaydaa (Ruba Blal), as they wait for his father, could be much longer than he initially anticipated. 

In what should be a desolate setting, writer and director Annemarie Jacir highlights moments of fun and images of the resoluteness of the human spirit in times of desperate conflict – the drive to keep on keeping on. Toddlers use a burlap tent as a slide, Tarek plays cars in the dirt with rubble and children attend school, although the futility of their education is palpable, and devastating.

Mahmoud Asfa charms as the wilful TarekTarek is suffocated by the oppressive claustrophobia of their tin dwellings – he doesn’t know which direction he came from, nor where he is going, and he channels his resolute (read: stubborn) nature into trying to get home to Palestine. 

The film shifts subtly from frames that are wide and close, full faces with dark eyes that haunt the screen, dusty and blue with a somber tinge, to scenes that open to full landscapes of dirt mountains and then dry green fields as Tarek learns to become a freedom fighter, much to his mother’s chagrin. Jacir captures admirably the essence of human nature to find reason, meaning and drive to survive – in each other as well as in action.

The ending of the film is as open as the journey of Palestine – an unending, unsolved problem, impossible to predict, impossible to conclude.

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Name that you would like to appear as the author of the comment
Jacir highlights moments of fun and images of the resoluteness of the human spirit in times of desperate conflict – the drive to keep on keeping on.

rating

3

explore topics

share this article

Help secure the future of arts journalism

In this era of algorithmic recommendation, opaquely sponsored content and AI slop, theartsdesk’s mission to preserve real journalistic and critical values has never been more important.

If you like what you see here, please join us 
in this mission.

Subscribing to the site will help us in our coming 
redesign and expansion.


If you do this before the 31st August this will be at our guaranteed founder’s rate: 
your subs will never increase again.

Subscribe now for £5 per month. 
or yearly for just £40.

Or if you simply want to support us with a one-off donation, you can do so here.

more film

Enthralling and witty political drama from 1960s East Germany
Matt Damon stars in Christopher Nolan's IMAX-sized recreation of Homer's epic poem
Dip your toes into these Homeric movies before Christopher Nolan’s 'The Odyssey' ties us to its mast
A Bellocchio classic is retooled as a stifllng rich-brats' revenge story
A potential camera in every hand: SMart celebrates smartphone directors
Hitchcockian black comedy from Luis Buñuel’s Mexican period
Olivia Wilde's snappy comedy on the perennial subject of reviving a failing marriage
Kiss kiss, bang bang in a moving Middle East documentary
David Vann's acclaimed novella transposed to the screen with mixed results
The most important 'how-to video' you are ever likely to see
Satyajit Ray's poignant, thoughtful drama, set in 1960s Calcutta
Superman's party girl cousin earns her stripes underwhelmingly