sun 25/06/2017

Life of a Mountain: A Year on Blencathra, BBC Four | reviews, news & interviews

Life of a Mountain: A Year on Blencathra, BBC Four

Life of a Mountain: A Year on Blencathra, BBC Four

Panoramic homage to a lesser-known Cumbrian peak

Blencathra: 'the mountaineer’s mountain', according to Wainwright

Two years ago BBC Four had a film about a year in the life of Scafell Pike. Arriving at glacial pace is the sequel: Life of a Mountain: A Year on Blencathra. The star this time round is more of a best supporting character actor than a headline performer. It’s only the 18th highest of England’s peaks. As one photographer explained, you can’t get a decent shot of all of its five-felled south-facing expanse. For a long time it even had the wrong name imposed on it: Saddleback, on account of the dipping ridge between its peaks. Alfred Wainwright, who still has the final word on these things in Cumbria, called it the mountaineer’s mountain.

Not that this film contained any bona fide mountaineering. Instead it met with fell runners, path-menders, sheep farmers, student ecologists, snowboarders and, at the top, ramblers from everywhere. It’s mainly the visitors who go up. Eighty percent of locals, reckoned Donald Angus of Threlkeld, aged 77, haven’t bothered. “You’re a bit funny in the head if you live here and go up.” We met a French woman called Marie-Pierre who runs the highest youth hostel in England at Skiddaw. A friend forced her up after eight years.

The local guides tell a different story. Alan Hinkes, whose OBE was much insisted upon in his caption label, had the Sharp Ridge all to himself one snowy winter day. This craggy ascent is so called because it offers sheer drops to left and right (though doesn’t look as quite as perilous as Crib Goch on Snowdon). David Powell-Thompson (pictured below), another guide, randomly escorted professional northerner Stuart Maconie and Irish stand-up Ed Byrne up one blustery Sunday. Maconie moaned quite a lot.

Life on a MOuntain: BlencathraTerry Abraham’s film was exceptionally easy on the eye. Montages of mountainscape, some of it caught by dronecam, wowed one’s retinas. Clouds flooded the valley beds, ridge prows retreated in a beautiful recession of tones, a cluster of fell-runners cast shadows like sheep, the sun set all Halloween orange. Poet Philip Houghton, bemoaning the Lake District's over-reliance on Wordsworth’s daffodils, recited his own butch homage to the mountain: “cloud ratcher, mist splitter, snow etcher, anvil to winter’s hammer blows”. 

The visual interludes felt even a little too plentiful, interludes in what was primarily a film about people’s relationship with indifferent nature. “It’s a really nice mountain,” said a boy at Threlkeld Primary School. There was much evidence to contradict him. While Marie-Pierre is happy with her partner and the radio and no mains electricity, solitude isn't everyone's cup of tea. Another section visited a hill farm which has been in one family for over 100 years. “We farm tourists now as well as sheep,” said Sarah Chaplin-Brice, who seems to live alone with her son Will. Loneliness is a problem which the film didn’t have the heart to go into. Last winter’s devastating floods destroyed their business and their problems multiplied. “It’s like a bereavement,” said Sarah.

Somewhere between an almanac and a palimpsest, the structure-light film didn’t really deploy a presenter. David Powell-Thompson introduced the mountain. Later Eric Robson did a piece to camera about the myths and legends attached to it, featuring everlasting fish and a spectral army and Arthur’s round table – hence the name, meaning Arthur’s seat. In a nice audio coup, the soundtrack with a yearning violin credited to Freddiehangoler/Soundgem Studios was sung a capella by a local choir called Sing Owt. Better head up it soon. After this enchanting postcard, England's 18th highest peak is not going to be its 18th most crowded.

(In the interests of balance, BBC Four's topographical tour next week is South Downs: England's Mountains Green. You won't need crampons for that.)

@JasperRees

Montages of mountainscape, some of it caught by dronecam, wowed one’s retinas

rating

Editor Rating: 
4
Average: 4 (1 vote)

Share this article

Comments

Over-hyped and intellectuslly photoshopped. Insincere and pretentious. Knowing the Dales and the Lakes so very well, I felt this film was not truthful, just a touristic filmic picture postcard. What a pity.

Very disappointing, what a missed opportunity, full of disjointed intervals, badly put together, the BBC can do so much better. what on earth is happening to the usual high standards?

I found this film beautiful and truly inspiring.

I thought that this was a breathtaking documentary. I've always ignored Blencathra because of its lack of height: I shall visit for sure at Easter. I'm sorry that the review didn't mention the wonderful song "The Mountain" by Lee Maddison, which was the highlight of the whole programme.

Add comment

Subscribe to theartsdesk.com

Thank you for continuing to read our work on theartsdesk.com. For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 10,000 pieces, we're asking for £2.95 per month or £25 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.

To take an annual subscription now simply click here.

And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a theartsdesk.com gift subscription?

newsletter

Get a weekly digest of our critical highlights in your inbox each Thursday!

Simply enter your email address in the box below

View previous newsletters