sat 10/12/2016

Downton Abbey: The Finale, ITV1 | reviews, news & interviews

Downton Abbey: The Finale, ITV1

Downton Abbey: The Finale, ITV1

Why it worked: four writers on theartsdesk explain the hit drama's appeal

'A weekend? What precisely is a weekend?' It's where you schedule a hit drama starring Dame Maggie Smith

Defying predictions that there would be no audience for a period costume drama set in an Edwardian country house, Downton Abbey has become the TV event of 2010. Episode one notched 11.6 million viewers (including repeats and ITV Player viewings), while episode two edged up to 11.8 million. The concluding episode seven threw all the cards in the air, blowing apart Mary and Matthew's romance, leaving Anna and Mr Bates dangling in limbo, and ending with the shattering news of Britain's declaration of war on Germany. There was even, briefly, a pregnancy for the fortysomething Countess of Grantham. 

The anguish of fans at the prospect of the first series coming to an end has been at least slightly assuaged by the news that a second series has already been commissioned, and overseas markets are battering at the doors of production company Carnival Films to get their hands on it. If Downton Abbey hasn't yet trounced The X Factor in the ratings war, it may none the less represent a watershed in British television. It has emphatically whipped the carpet out from under those who have tried to dance on the grave of quality TV drama, and ITV's chief executive Adam Crozier is even talking about Downton as his spearhead in a drive to take the network in an artsier, more drama-orientated direction.

As the first series completed its run, four writers on theartsdesk explain why, in their view, the series has worked so well, and also nominate their favourite upstairs character (excluding the Dowager Countess of Dame Maggie, who will no doubt be walking off with the Bafta), favourite downstairs character and, in a series full of them, the most far-fetched plotline. We urge you to join the debate and make your own nominations in the comments section.

Adam Sweeting:

It's odd that Downton Abbey's writer, Julian Fellowes, has been complaining about criticism of the show from "the Left", since a lot of it seems to have been on the letters page of The Daily Telegraph (the stuff about double yellow lines on the road and visible TV aerials). But the salient fact is that viewers are engaging intimately with Downton Abbey, to a fanatical and nitpicking degree, in a way which surely makes a nonsense of party lines, despite some kneejerk moaning about "toffs".

DOWNTON_ABBEY_EP4_16Indeed, this is where the true cunning of Fellowes's conception lies, since his masters-and-servants microclimate within Downton Abbey is inextricably linked to events in the world outside. It's true that the show is riddled with anachronisms - the Earl and Countess of Grantham would make fairly liberal-minded parents even in 2010, their politically radical daughter Lady Sybil always looks as if she's off for a weekend at Glastonbury, and even Maggie Smith's pantomime dowager has a heart, although perhaps not of gold, behind that facade of withering haughtiness.

But what makes the drama grip is the way that irresistible social and political change is ticking away like a bomb buried under Downton's manicured lawns, whether it's the Irish chauffeur with a passion for socialism or the rise of the middle classes represented by cousin Matthew. And every character and storyline is overshadowed by the knowledge that this entire world is about to slide into the volcano of the Great War.

Favourite upstairs character? Robert, Earl of Grantham (Hugh Bonneville), a man of superhuman tolerance and reason.
Favourite downstairs character? Anna, the head housemaid (Joanne Froggatt, pictured above right), outwardly gentle but inwardly tough as old boots.
Most far-fetched plotline? Thomas the footman's gay conspiracy with the Duke of Crowborough to steal the Downton inheritance.

Alexandra Coghlan:

While harking back to the glory days of ITV costume drama, to The Jewel in the Crown, Brideshead Revisited and of course Upstairs Downstairs, Downton Abbey is also the canniest and most topical piece of programming currently gracing our screens. A world on the cusp of change; a ruling order under threat from the discontented masses; an international crisis looming ever closer: sound familiar? Downton Abbey is current affairs in corsets and crinolines – the sartorial spoonful of sugar that helps even the sharpest of social medicines go down.

DOWNTON_ABBEY_EP3_06With consummate skill, Julian Fellowes has held up the mirror for us, and the graceful, soft-focus images it reflects back have proved seductive indeed. Who needs to confront reactionary Conservative policy when instead you can have Maggie Smith in a hat that could double as a soup tureen, inquiring: “A weekend? What precisely is a weekend?”

Who would trade the flesh wounds of contemporary social realism for its sepia-softened Edwardian counterpart, complete with orderly, cabbage-throwing riot and obligatory scratch to the temple. Period details and contemporary attitudes (the footman’s notorious “One swallow doesn’t make a summer” sexual encounter with a young aristo comes to mind) make for a combination just the right side of kitsch. Authentic it ain’t, but enjoyable? Unquestionably.

Favourite upstairs character? Lady Mary (Michelle Dockery, pictured above left), the envy of her sisters with the best outfits and the best lines.
Favourite downstairs character? The staunchly moral Mr Bates (Brendan Coyle).
Most far-fetched plotline? Carson's shady past as a music-hall entertainer.

Veronica Lee:

Downton Abbey has had quality written all over it - superb cast, terrific location, great costumes - but perhaps the £7 million ITV have spent on it shows most in the way its multiple storylines have been allowed to develop almost naturalistically over seven episodes. Writer and creator Julian Fellowes has proved himself a worthy contender for any number of awards, and I thought in the series’ very opening scenes – where he effortlessly introduced a large cast over the titles - he showed himself to be a master of economical exposition. I also love the comedy, some of it laugh-out-loud, but much of it subtle.

DOWNTON_ABBEY_EP5_08As to all the supposedly wrong historical detail, there are times when some of the language has indeed jarred and one is aware of a modern eye looking at a time long gone, but surely being able to nitpick is part of the pleasure? I think Downton feeds into a pleasurable reminiscence of those Sunday evenings when British families sat down together to watch, depending on the generation they belong to, The Forsyte Saga, The Onedin Line or (more recently) Cranford. In the age of iPlayer, Sky+ and TiVo, people have been switching off their phones and getting comfy on their sofas to watch Downton Abbey in real time, so that they may discuss it with their friends immediately after, or the next day at work or school. And that has made it an inclusive, rather than just an individual, pleasure.

Favourite upstairs character? Lady Cora (Elizabeth McGovern, pictured above right), an outsider who quietly gets her way.
Favourite downstairs character? Miss O'Brien (Siobhan Finneran), a bitter, twisted thing of warped beauty.
Most far-fetched plotline? The Irish socialist chauffeur becoming matey with the Earl's youngest daughter.

Jasper Rees:

Downton Abbey was addictive despite often quite glaring flaws. In seven instalments the drama covered the three years from the sinking of the Titanic to the outbreak of the Great War, and yet everything that happened upstairs and down in the Crawleys’ world took place in glorious summer. Among other evidence that things in this Edwardian capsule were locked in evergreen permanence, there were two plotlines involving a servant with an embarrassing past and no fewer than three involving servants trying to hide an ailment.

DOWNTON_ABBEY_EP3_11Perhaps in tribute to the genre from which it derives everything apart from the costumes, in the final episode there were even two plotlines with a starring role for a bar of soap. As Lord Grantham would no doubt concur, if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.

In dramaturgical terms, His Grace was the biggest victim of Julian Fellowes’s well-documented fondness for the old order. Fellowes's scripts embalmed that fantasy of a hierarchical society in eternal stasis by giving Hugh Bonneville's kindly patriarch an essentially plotless existence. He didn't want a scene over the petty larceny of the footman Thomas, and his wishes were met. No matter that audiences were crying out for a show-down. Nor did the Earl of Grantham ever find out about Lady Mary's tumble with the Turk. Indeed Lady Cora's terminal horror at her daughter's disgrace lasted the length of a commercial break. Meanwhile, as a storyline the entail went deep undercover for several hours of screen time.

The cast had worked out exactly what was wanted of them and delivered it with consummate skill.

Visually, too, it’s all been a bit of a dog’s dinner. The three different directors (Brian Percival, Ben Bolt and Brian Kelly) pursued widely varying notions of how the stories should unfold pictorially. Half the time one character would plod into shot to begin a dialogue with another seated character, but then there were weird moments of experimentalism. When Lady Mary overheard one titbit, for example, the camera homed in from behind on Michelle Dockery’s ear like something straight out of Buñuel. For one of the flower-show scenes I could have sworn Tristan Tzara was in the edit suite doing his Dadaist cut-up technique. And because she had so many tête-à-têtes, we saw far too much of the back of Dame Maggie’s head (pictured below).

DOWNTON_ABBEY_EP5_18The worst of it was that, defying a basic rule of good popular drama, not a single plotline was satisfactorily resolved. One housemaid got a job as a secretary: that was it. By the final episode, Bates's stoicism had become actively anti-dramatic; it's a measure of Brendan Coyle's charisma that he contrived to deliver Bates's enigmatic final speech without projectiles being hurled at screens up and down the land.

Some of these infelicities were doubtless the result of budgetary constraints. In Granada’s golden age, Downton Abbey might in real terms have cost three times as much. So how on earth did it work so gloriously? For one, like all good soap, it was just terribly moreish. And as great British television actors always will, the cast had worked out exactly what was wanted of them and delivered with consummate skill. Finally, for good or ill, the great British viewing public seems to like drama about a world pickled in aspic where everyone knows their place. The old respect for deference and heritage dies hard. But all those loose ends? They amount to a kind of sadism.

Favourite upstairs character? Mrs Crawley (Penelope Wilton), the bluestocking who relishes a (very polite) dogfight.
Favourite downstairs character? Thomas (Rob James-Collier, pictured above left), the dastardly gay first footman with a finger in all the wrong pies.
Most far-fetched plotline? The Turkish diplomat's inconvenient death by coitus.

Watch Julian Fellowes and some of the cast talking about Downton Abbey:

Fellowes embalmed that fantasy of a society in eternal stasis by giving Hugh Bonneville's kindly patriarch an essentially plotless existence

Share this article

Comments

Interesting what you say about Downton Abbey steeped in eternal summer, Jasper. I only saw one well-acted-but-so-what episode, disqualifying me from comment above, in which it seemed to be emulating the social concerns and Historical Relevance of Cranford. And that, so wonderful in its main seires, also committed the cardinal sin of running the drama of its second 'return to...' episode from October to December; yet in every scene except the final one with fake snow, the sun shone and the trees were in full leaf...

What a privilege to watch some great British drama again, it was like watching old scheduled TV when we had 3-4 channels. A great casting and story had me guessing from start to finish what was going to happen, and I was wrong. I don’t usually plan to watch TV now a days due to the rubbish it transmits but over the last 6 months or so have increasingly made a point in watching ITV1, BBC1, BBC2 and reduced the amount of time watching satellite TV. There have been a number of other good dramas but this was the penultimate, wonder how many awards it will get. I recently sat down to think how many original dramas, shows, documentaries are shown on satellite channels (Except the BBC1, BBC2, ITV1) for the first time, could not think of any, just repeats and reality shows all the time. I thinked the age of good, original television television had died with the introduction of satellite and cable rubbish, it seems everyone wants quantity not quality or is it that we are all pushed that way by the satellite and cable companies. Well, keep up the good dramas; I don’t mind paying a licence fee for.

I absolutely loved every moment of Downton Abbey, from the opening music to the close of the final credits. It helped that I had been eagerly awaiting it since around June when I first heard it would be shown, but there's always the danger of even a slight feeling of let-down when there's so much pre-publicity. However, every shot (even those picked up on with glee by the blooper-spotters!) was a complete joy and the characters brought the setting to life with the delicate touch of authenticity. I am immensely looking forward to the second series, and keen to see how the lives of everyone change during the war. The loose ends I don't think of as sadistic, more as gentle teasers now we know there's definitely a further series (hopefully more than one). If, however, that had been the finish of it, I'd have been bouncing off the ceiling!

I found Downton Abbey hugely entertaining. I think it's very difficult for television drama to please everyone, and I think they did a very good job at trying to please most. Getting the correct balance between historical accuracy and writing for a modern audience is always fraught with difficulty, but I think overall they succeeded. There is not enough period drama on television as far as I'm concerned and I hope the 'powers that be' will see that although expensive we really need to see more quality productions like these. More please!

We are just viewing Downton Abby here in Vancouver Canada this month and what a treat it is. I loved every minute of it, the costumes and the acting and the settings. Great job, give us more BBC, this is something worth watching! Vancouver Canada

Here in the United States, Downton Abbey is the first scripted program I've seen in almost fifteen years that I've been able to get truly excited about. What fantastic scripts! The characters, the humor, the consistent magical fascination of the stories... May this wonderful ride continue for many years to come!

What a splendid refreshment the First Season has been! Yes, one could pick nits, but why bother when you can submerge yourself in the glorious romanticism of days gone by? I'm a Yank and believe me, we also have our classes and their issues, despite how we pretend otherwise. Who couldn't root for Bates and Anna? Or wish Thomas his comeuppance? And Lady Mary, what a gorgeous pill but so difficult to swallow! Sweet, terrified by Life Daisy, finally finding her voice. Matthew Crawley, dignified and resigned to his Duty. The Dowager Countess, with the Best Lines Ever! “A weekend? What precisely is a weekend?” ~ this will go down in History. and Lady Cora, with all those wry knowing smiles... All of it, each moment and scene special, to be savored like cognac

The final episode did have a feel of "throw out some new threads but don't tie up any of the old ones". Some innovations of serial tv that weren't around in the 70's include definite character arcs and definite character ends. The actors do a very fine job, and writing that doesn't do them justice seems unfair. The whole "now she's pregnant, now she's not" was not merely contrived, it seemed a slight to the people who had to perform it. Something that struck me very forcefully during the run of "Mad Men" was that the characters were behaving like people who had taken in modes of interaction they had seen in contemporary drama of that time--in plays by Miller, Inge or Anderson. I wonder if someone in this production might want to take a look at a play or two by Granville Barker. And if someone's trying to exploit this Edwardian opening, perhaps they could extract "Mr. American" from development purgatory.

did anybody notice the comparison with the flower show scene in the 40's film mrs miniver featuring the characters lady belddon/mr. ballard and an awfully similar scene in DA ?

Add comment

Subscribe to theartsdesk.com

Thank you for continuing to read our work on theartsdesk.com. For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 10,000 pieces, we're asking for £2.95 per month or £25 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.

To take an annual subscription now simply click here.

And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a theartsdesk.com gift subscription?

newsletter

Get a weekly digest of our critical highlights in your inbox each Thursday!

Simply enter your email address in the box below

View previous newsletters