Britten Sinfonia, Wigmore Hall | reviews, news & interviews
Britten Sinfonia, Wigmore Hall
Britten Sinfonia, Wigmore Hall
A punishing introduction to classical music for youngsters
Wednesday, 16 December 2009
A truly terrifying sight this afternoon. The Wigmore Hall: full of children. A group of 50 10- to 13-year-olds were filing in to hear their first classical concert. On this one event a lifetime’s attitude to an entire art form would be based. It was make or break time. The concert would have to have been very carefully chosen. Hm. What had these wise teachers picked for these impressionable young rookies to ease their ears into the tough world of classical music? A lunchtime chamber recital of the works of Guillaume de Machaut, Harrison Birtwistle and Johannes Ockeghem. My instinct was to call social services.
Now if you’re expecting me to report that actually the kids jumped up and down with joy when they heard the Birtwistle and demanded an encore, then you are going to be pretty disappointed. Of course what happened was what always happens when children who have lived their entire lives swimming in the amniotic fluid of pop are sat down in front of some classical music. See above.
They weren’t entirely to blame. Even by the standards of the Wigmore Hall this was esoteric programming. Pieces of Machaut, rearranged by Birtwistle for a small chamber group (string quartet, flute, clarinet, piano and percussion), interspersed with real bits of Birtwistle, bits of J S Bach rearranged by Birtwistle, a piece by contemporary composer Christian Mason (whose influences include Birtwistle) and a piece by Ockeghem, described in the programme as containing “one of the most convoluted and bewildering canons in all western music”, were played through without a pause. Good. So nothing too challenging, then.
Don't get me wrong. It was a great concert in many ways. Beautifully played and all that. The hocket compositional technique, which requires two performers to play a single melodic line in the form of a tennis rally, hitting notes to one and another, created a pretty fiendish level of difficulty and was executed with due diligence. A lot of this fiendishness was, I think, down to Birtwistle’s arranging, which required the string players to play or suggest each notes’ harmonics, the ethereal overtones that shadow each note and are only elicited when a string is touched, not pressed. But none of it - really none - was appropriate for an adult rookie, let alone a small, wide-eyed child.
The school party seemed as little convinced by Birtwistle’s chamber music as I have always been. His Double Hocket (2007) for piano trio was spritely and splashy, with a few nice turns, but little else to recommend it. The Lied (2006) coldly juxtaposes a trudging piano ground and a singing cello line, while his Verses (1965) for clarinet and piano from his youth have a call-of-the-wild presence to them.
It was difficult to criticise the arrangements of Bach's The Art of Fugue, seeing as the wispy legato feel to the Contrapunctus VII, the sense that bows had been glued to strings, was probably not the fault of the performers. There was something thrillingly rough-edged about first violinist Jacqueline Shave’s front-running in the Contrapunctus XII.
The Christian Mason piece, Noctilucence (2009), proved a rather empty affair in contrast to all this contrapuntal weaving. Deliberately so, by all accounts. The work is meant to mimic the highest clouds in our stratosphere. It did this well enough but then became fixated on some rather too pronounced and hoary musical ideas: a piano glissando and a boorish lyrical idea.
To finish we had some curiously festive Ockeghem, his Ut heremita solus, after which I heard a child scream, “That’s so cool!” Not the world’s youngest Ockeghem fan, sadly, it had simply started to snow and the faces of three rows of bored children suddenly lit up with excitement.
Subscribe to theartsdesk.com
Thank you for continuing to read our work on theartsdesk.com. For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 15,000 pieces, we're asking for £5 per month or £40 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.
To take a subscription now simply click here.
And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a theartsdesk.com gift subscription?
more Classical music
Classical CDs: Cowhorns, gloves and marching drums
Contemporary sounds from Norway, plus rediscovered American and a brass dectet
Kolesnikov, Wigmore Hall review - celestial navigation through a cabinet of wonders
Quirky but brilliant programme finds connections between unlikely bedfellows
Orchestre Révolutionnaire et Romantique, Sousa, St Martin-in-the-Fields review - Beethoven, younger than springtime
An exuberant cobweb-clearing symphony cycle
Hough, Hallé, Elder, Bridgewater Hall, Manchester review - affection and adventure
Sir Stephen Hough’s piano concerto receives its European premiere
Bavouzet, Manchester Camerata, Takács-Nagy, Stoller Hall, Manchester review - fun with abandon
Approaching the final goal of ‘Mozart, made in Manchester’
Dunedin Consort, Mulroy, Wigmore Hall review - songs of love old and new
First-rate chamber choir explore contemporary and Renaissance approaches to amour
Coote, LSO, Tilson Thomas, Barbican review - the triumph of life
A great, ailing conductor rises to Mahler's mightiest challenge
Britten Sinfonia, The Marian Consort, Milton Court review - a journey around turbulent spirit Gesualdo
Contemporary homages among the works in this celebration of the Renaissance 'badass'
Classical CDs: Coffee, peppercorns and puppets
A prolific conductor's centenary celebrated, plus Hungarian ballet music and baroque keyboard concertos
Sansara, Manchester Collective, Bridgewater Hall, Manchester review - sense of a unique experience
Three world premieres all respond to Feldman’s 'Rothko Chapel'
Gomyo, National Symphony Orchestra, Kuokman, National Concert Hall, Dublin review - painful brilliance around a heart of darkness
A violinist for all facets of a towering Shostakovich masterpiece
Remembering conductor Andrew Davis (1944-2024)
Fellow conductors, singers, instrumentalists and administrators recall a true Mensch
Add comment