Gangster Squad | Film reviews, news & interviews
Ruben Fleischer swaps zombies for gangsters with mixed results
Jean-Luc Godard once said, "All you need for a movie is a gun and a girl". Aside from upping the ante to include a formidable arsenal of the former, Ruben Fleischer's Gangster Squad hangs its fedora on that wisdom. It might however have aimed a little higher, as its glamour-and-guns story is trimmed to the point of frustration. There's action aplenty but with a story told in quips and shorthand, this is the gangster movie as entertainment pure and simple.
Gangster Squad is a heavily fictionalised account of the Los Angeles Police Department's post-war assault on organised crime, loosely based on the non-fiction book by Paul Lieberman. Set in L.A. in 1949, the gangster squad of the title are a team of six police officers - vigilantes with badges - unafraid to adopt the violent methods of those they pursue as a means to restoring law and order. They're led by staunch war hero Sergeant John O'Mara (Josh Brolin - whose authoritative, chiselled mug makes him as appropriate a 1940s screen cop as it's possible to find in the modern age).
Ryan Gosling (pictured right) adds a more modern flavour as Sergeant Jerry Wooters, who at first seems to have lazily accepted the corruption of his city. As he says to O'Mara, "The whole town's underwater and you're grabbing a bucket when you should be grabbing a bathing suit". Wooters is snapped out of his apathy when he witnesses a heinous crime and he joins the taskforce, alongside conscientious brain-box Giovanni Ribisi, old-timer sharpshooter Robert Patrick, and Michael Peña and Anthony Mackie - who are almost exclusively defined by their ethnicity. On the orders of Chief Parker (a comically croaky Nick Nolte) they're to take down crime boss Mickey Cohen (Sean Penn, sporting a giant rubber hooter). Emma Stone (pictured below left) plays the aforementioned girl, Cohen's (fictional) moll Grace Faraday, who also becomes dangerously involved with Wooters.
If it feels as if you've been hearing about Gangster Squad for ages, that's because the release was put back by several months when the Aurora cinema massacre in July last year prompted the filmmakers to remove a cinema-based shoot-out, which had been glimpsed in the film's original trailer. The removal of this sequence and the resulting reshoots haven't had a discernible impact but the film's approach as a whole often jars. If it's economical with the truth it's also all too sparing in the presentation of its predictable plot. Ultra-violence aside, this is more of a stylish box-ticking caper in the mould of the Ocean's movies than a meaty thriller a la L.A. Confidential.
Yet once you get past the lack of depth and surprises, there's plenty to enjoy: Gangster Squad whips along apace, providing ample, efficiently executed action. Fleischer's debut Zombieland was a riot, swapping scares for effervescent irreverence and he certainly knows how to entertain. Will Beall's script is relentlessly posturing but authentically hard-boiled and the film more than looks the part, boasting a rich digital aesthetic, to-die-for costumes and fabulous sets; the recreation of Cohen's real hang-out, Slapsy Maxie's, being a particular highlight.
Gosling and Stone are an appositely gorgeous couple at its centre and Gosling, as ever, does a lot with a little. However, if Stone has screen charisma in spades she lacks a hard-edge and is not given any clear motivation for her dalliance with the villainous Cohen, while her redemptive act doesn't ring entirely true (probably because it isn't). Penn gives it large as a cartoon gangster but his performance just serves to remind us that this isn't a film to take particularly seriously.
This is perfectly diverting Saturday-night-out entertainment but snappy dialogue and spectacular shoot-outs can't hide paper thin characterisations and an insubstantial story.
Watch the trailer for Gangster Squad
Subscribe to theartsdesk.com
Thank you for continuing to read our work on theartsdesk.com. For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 10,000 pieces, we're asking for £2.95 per month or £25 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.
To take an annual subscription now simply click here.
And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a theartsdesk.com gift subscription?
Spielberg's warm-hearted Cold War thriller is lit up by Tom Hanks and Mark Rylance
Gruelling Boston crime saga brings out the best of Johnny Depp
Oscar-winning masterpiece from the Czech New Wave
Cate Blanchett and Rooney Mara are the star-crossed lovers of a ravishing romance
Fine performances in a touching eating-disorder drama from Sweden
Reappraising George Hoellering - his screen version of TS Eliot's verse drama, and remarkable documentaries
theartsdesk recommends the half-dozen top movies out now
Kate Winslet revenge drama needs serious alterations
Very bearable lightness of being in off-beat Mexican New Wave urban comedy
The only way is Essex to Cambridgeshire for lovelorn Romantic poet John Clare
The movie star who dreamed of being a race ace
Masterful Fassbinder-produced exploration of Germany’s 1920’s serial killer