WNO Chorus and Orchestra, Poppen, St David's Hall, Cardiff | Classical music reviews, news & interviews
WNO Chorus and Orchestra, Poppen, St David's Hall, Cardiff
Recently deceased Hans Werner Henze movingly memorialised in his own Requiem
Speaking about the Requiem he composed in 1990 in memory of the London Sinfonietta’s long-time artistic director Michael Vyner, Hans Werner Henze always talked as a believing atheist. “Paradise is here or ought to be,” he insisted, “not later, when nothing else happens;” and “In this world there is no hereafter, only presence: you can meet angels and devils in the street at any time.”
So it was a surprise to find a lot more spiritual power radiating from the three movements of the Requiem that Christoph Poppen conducted in this concert by the Welsh National Opera Chorus and Orchestra than from the Requiem by that good if not over-devout Catholic, W.A. Mozart. The surprise was on a number of levels. Henze’s Requiem is instrumental, not vocal, so the textual meaning of the various movements has to be taken on trust. Like so much Henze, these are rambling, unfocused pieces, with moments of intense beauty amid a prevailing atmosphere of mild self-indulgence.
You might say that the very act of composing a Requiem omitting the words is a kind of special pleading: trading on the sentiment of the words while avoiding their connotations. Perhaps. But all such feelings were swept away on this occasion by the sheer concentration of Poppen’s conducting and the Welsh playing.
Poppen seemed to have decided that one committed Requiem per evening was quite enough
The pieces were well chosen to serve as a memorial to the composer himself, who died three weeks ago at the age of 86. The “Introitus”, with its delicate, reflective ritornelli for solo piano (beautifully played by Simon Phillippo) and harsh outbursts of protest on the brass; the “Agnus Dei”, alternating piano and softly textured string polyphonies; and the “Sanctus”, with its brilliant part for solo trumpet (Dean Wright), echoed from the farthest reaches of the hall by two more trumpets, like the angels summoning the reluctant composer to confront the deity whose existence he denies.
All this was wonderfully stirring, and in an odd way an improvement on the complete, nine-movement Requiem, which tends to overdo the brilliance and the stridency, and, frankly, to go on much too long (more than an hour). Intensity is apt to dissipate in Henze’s longer scores. Here it was firmly maintained, with the help of a touching introductory speech by the conductor (pictured right), claiming Henze, somewhat speculatively, as one of the most important 20th-century composers, and less questionably as a fine human being. Henze had aesthetic enemies, and he had political ones: but I never met a personal one.
After this, Mozart fell unexpectedly flat, despite a polished performance by the chorus and orchestra, and at least one outstanding soloist in the diminutive shape of Elizabeth Watts, recently a fine Fiordiligi under tricky circumstances with WNO. Poppen seemed to have decided that one committed Requiem per evening was quite enough, and scampered through the work as if anxious to prove that Mozart, too, thought the hereafter a mere abstraction. Music that can be transcendent was reduced to mere excellence. The professional chorus sang immaculately, but without the devotion of struggling amateurs; and the other three soloists, less highlit by the music, practically vanished.
The listening mind also wandered. Did Süssmayr really compose so much music of real power: most of the Lacrimosa (pace the concert’s programme note), all of the Benedictus and Agnus Dei? Or was he working from sketches, now lost, by the dying Master himself? After all, the earlier sections of the work certainly existed in score, incomplete in orchestral detail, but fully composed. Süssmayr could work directly on Mozart’s autograph. Sketch material for the later movements would have to be written up and the sketches themselves probably discarded, not out of deviousness or vandalism, but simply because nobody would have thought them worth keeping.
Or was it, as Brahms later alleged, simply rather easy to write music in Mozart’s day? Maybe; but not Mozart’s music.
- Find further concerts in the St.David's Hall International Concert Series
- Find further performances by Welsh National Opera
Subscribe to theartsdesk.com
Thank you for continuing to read our work on theartsdesk.com. For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 10,000 pieces, we're asking for £2.95 per month or £25 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.
To take an annual subscription now simply click here.
And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a theartsdesk.com gift subscription?
more Classical music
Gender trouble at the Proms for Alice Coote and Handel
Great mezzo and bright young choir fly up, orchestra and conductor remain below
Glamorous visitors bring a crazy concerto, luminous Mahler, and a bit of chrome-plating
Superlative performance of Sibelius's early epic coincides with Tolkien publication
Beethoven proves immune to Ticciati magic
Perfection within limits from a great conductor, pianist and chamber orchestra
Contemporary repertoire from Iceland, Viennese symphonies and Spanish music from France
An emotional hail-and-farewell to the Proms from a superb German orchestra
Blocks of Bartók hit hard, but an orchestrated slab of earlyish Shostakovich falls flat
Immersive Bach experience on the Edinburgh Fringe
Compelling Shostakovich rounds out a great partnership's weekend at the Proms
The masterly Latvian and his American orchestra stun in toweringly great Mahler