The Sound and the Fury, BBC Four | Classical music reviews, news & interviews
The Sound and the Fury, BBC Four
The rest is a spring: series on 20th-century music moves in double quick time
As Julian Lloyd Webber combatively suggests of certain strands of 20th-century music: “Let’s make a noise no one likes. If the audience likes it, you have failed as a composer.” In general, though, the first programme in this welcome three-part series is if anything too measured and respectful in guiding us through the labyrinths of 20th-century music – from Debussy to Richard Strauss (relatively easy on the ears) via the tougher, spikier Schoenberg and Webern.
Partly encouraged by the fact that Alex Ross’s The Rest Is Noise has become a bestseller (who knew so many people could be interested in Xenakis and Berg?), The Sound and the Fury handily coincides with the Southbank’s season of the same name. A classier version of what has become the BBC Four house style for music TV, it featured stock footage, snippets of performance and an array of interviews. A fairly heavyweight bunch of composers included Steve Reich, John Adams, George Benjamin, Meredith Monk and Pierre Boulez - and in the next two, John Tavener, Philip Glass and Arvo Pärt. Other pronouncements came from music historians and critics, notably Ross (pictured below), and Schoenberg's daughter. Even so, I wouldn’t be surprised if programme-maker Ian MacMillan had to put up with execs saying "Can’t we get anyone sexier from the pop world, like Björk?"
The Rite of Spring's rhythms were like facing a boxer not knowing where the next punch was coming from
A problem with securing a plethora of pundits is they have to operate at sound-bite length. Some here were memorable: Ross on how The Rite of Spring’s rhythms were like facing a boxer not knowing where the next punch was coming from, or Tom Service arguing that listening to Webern’s unearthly weightless music is like watching a plant or crystal under a microscope (John Adams suggested it is “emotionally stingy”). But there was no time to elaborate on or develop a coherent argument.
This first episode, entitled Wrecking Ball, did make lots of useful connections: we heard how the prickly, tense music of the Viennese School had some parallels with painters like Egon Schiele, how the lack of any “home” key was perhaps a Jewish reaction to anti-Semitism, and how in general the 20th century was the most violent century ever, so why wouldn’t the music reflect that? But it may well have worked better with a more opinionated, central figure who could make clear that their choices of what to cover (no British music worth mentioning in this episode) was a personal one, rather than attempting and failing to be “definitive”.
By covering so much territory (the first episode took us up to the Second World War, and mentioned that shocking fact that many composers were sympathetic to Fascism), the drawback was Stravinsky was "done" in 10 minutes. The advantage was instant connections – how Charles Ives used vernacular music in a similar way to Stravinsky, for example - and it may be that some viewers who love Stravinsky will be encouraged to discover Ives.
The production values and commissioned performances are of high-quality and as a basic introduction into the sometimes hermetic world of some 20th-century music it works (and the next two programmes will have more live composers to interview). One can only hope for more in-depth programmes on specific movements or composers which can do more than skate over the surface. Meanwhile, interest piqued, we can all go to the Southbank for several hundred hours of their 20th-century season.
Subscribe to theartsdesk.com
Thank you for continuing to read our work on theartsdesk.com. For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 10,000 pieces, we're asking for £2.95 per month or £25 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.
To take an annual subscription now simply click here.
And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a theartsdesk.com gift subscription?
more Classical music
The biggest symphony is wholehearted but missing the bigger picture
Rainbow colours in Sibelius's masterly incidental music for 'The Tempest'
Subtle connections help frame fascinating portrait of the Dutch pioneer
Lively Russian nationalist goody-bag not quite filled to the brim
Star soprano shines in adventurous new works
Early works from a French 20th century giant, Russian piano concertos and Australian saxophone music
29-year-old Lithuanian conductor follows Andris Nelsons in Birmingham
Grieg’s bold Nordic spirit conveyed, but often at the expense of his charm
Young conductor leads dynamic and detailed Haydn, Szymanowski and Dvořák
An ecologically themed pairing of Beethoven and Raskatov, memorable for all the right and wrong reasons
French piano preludes, British quartets and 14th-century choral music refracted through modern ears
Well planned tribute to a great French composer who bucked the fashion