The Promise, Trafalgar Studios | Theatre reviews, news & interviews
The Promise, Trafalgar Studios
Russian drama fires up after the interval, abetted by its fine cast
An expert cast delivers on their promise in Aleksei Arbuzov's triangular Russian drama from 1965 of the same name, which offers up war and peace and the shifting tides of love. There's so much of the last, in fact, that Alex Sims's production at times plays out like Design For Living set against a soundscape of shelling and the occasional nod to Hitler and Stalin. Spanning more than 17 years in the lives of two men and a woman who survive the ravages of war only to face the separate ambush that comes with passion, the play transcends its soupier soap operatics thanks chiefly to the individual and collective talents of the trio on view before us.
At first, truth to tell, I wasn't sure whether the material might not sink its cunningly assembled cast, which includes a fast-rising TV star in Joanna Vanderham (The Paradise), here marking her professional stage debut, and two young but comparatively seasoned theatre names in Max Bennett (pictured below right with Vanderham) and Gwilym Lee. Both actors have done stints at the Donmar, the producing entity behind this third and final Trafalgar Studios season programmed to showcase the work of erstwhile Donmar resident directors who have here been given a spotlight all their own. But just when it looks as if an abiding shrillness and artificiality may well bring proceedings down, a post-interval rise in emotional temperature sends the pulse racing; the second half is very strong, indeed.
Up until the half, one can grasp how it is that a 1967 Broadway staging of this play, its cast including no less a line-up than Ian McKellen, Eileen Atkins, and Ian McShane, lasted 23 performances, and why Nicolas Kent's 2002 Tricycle Theatre revival got sniffy reviews. (I missed that one.) Set during the siege of Leningrad in 1942, the play's first act is given over to talk of corpse-strewn streets and fallen soldiers next to which the antics of the three teenagers on view before us seem trivial or cutesy or both. While one of course accepts the notion that love is sewn - in fact can often flourish - amidst devastation, the unfolding dynamics pay startlingly short shrift to the grievous losses sustained by the characters, as if the loss of a sibling or a parent were a minor inconvenience on the way to an amorous fumble.
The narrative, and Penelope Skinner's new English-language version of Ariadne Nicolaeff's pre-existing translation, is on far surer footing once electricity enters the equation in more ways than one. The years pass, Mike Britton's set gets a makeover allowing for not one but two rather remarkable bedspreads, and the roundelay of affections reasserts itself in ever-shifting ways, Vanderham's budding medic, Lika, the inevitable erotic pivot amid a milieu in which the poet Leonidik (Lee) and bridge-builder Marat (Bennett) are given the occasional bromance moment to call their own. (Skinner's language, too, allows for a "hey guys" here and a "no way" there. Oh, and "imbued" where presumably the word intended is "imbibed".)
Of the cast, only Lee (pictured left with Vanderham) looks even remotely as if his character might have had a glancing knowledge of war, the others appearing disconcertingly milk-fed and robust, their reported privations notwithstanding. But as the calamity (and worse) outside gives way to a hothouse of feeling undimmed by the passage of time, all three performers connect to the gathering intensity of a piece in which the sudden chime of a doorball tends to reposition affections as if from scratch.
Calling to mind a (much) younger Kate Winslet, Vanderham leaves no doubt that the stage is as much her natural habitat as the screen, and Bennett survives some fairly marked changes in hairstyle to articulate the "promise" of the title, its actual fulfillment up for grabs. Best of all is the open-faced Lee as a battle-scarred poet who, luckily, is denied the banal rhetoric ("without you, I have nothing") that sometimes besets the others. While the writing on occasion suggests an Andrew Lloyd Webber power ballad waiting to happen, this superb actor's performance really sings.
- The Promise is at Trafalgar Studios until 8 December
Subscribe to theartsdesk.com
Thank you for continuing to read our work on theartsdesk.com. For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 7,000 pieces, we're asking for £2.95 per month or £25 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.
To take an annual subscription now simply click here.
And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a theartsdesk.com gift subscription?
Designer rises to challenge of spectacular new venue
Howard Brenton’s First World War play is interesting, but not always convincing
An underwhelming production, but Maxine Peake is gripping as the young Prince
Enda Walsh's unsettling comedy triumphs at the Lyttelton
Powerful revival of Philip Ridley’s 1994 shock-fest proves that it’s a contemporary classic
Fearless foursome spoofs the poker-faced and the overblown in magnificent Menier transfer
Let the right Mormons in: a bit of everything in theartsdesk's tips
Pigott-Smith is the jewel in the crown of a provocative political comedy
Revived one-man show serves up a smorgasbord of comic treats
Sam Shepard’s tale of sibling rivalry and the sad underbelly of the American Dream prevails against almost too much mayhem
Great war story: on adapting Pat Barker's 'Regeneration' for the theatre
A witty dissection of modern parenthood shies away from real taboos