Dear World, Charing Cross Theatre | Theatre reviews, news & interviews
Dear World, Charing Cross Theatre
Eco-drama meets gentle whimsy as this chamber staging wins a quirky, long-neglected show its rightful place
It's odd that Jerry Herman merits only a passing mention in Stephen Sondheim's two-volume autobiographical take on Broadway words and music, Finishing the Hat and Look, I Made a Hat. In a couple of subjects Herman chose no less daringly than the master. Yet while La Cage aux Folles is now so entrenched that we forget its original boldness in asserting a loving gay relationship, Dear World's eccentric mix of eco-plea and nostalgia has yet to be established as a bittersweet chamber piece.
Where it only took Sondheim's Merrily We Roll Along 11 years to progress from flop to classic, Dear World has taken 44. Its time has finally come underneath the arches of Charing Cross in the intimate setting Herman always wanted, crowned this time by the supreme grace of Betty Buckley.
Her predecessor as Countess Aurelia, the Madwoman of Chaillot as adapted from Giraudoux’s 1943 play of that name, was the great Angela Lansbury, whose delivery of a string of terrific songs on the 1969 Broadway cast recording has kept the show’s memory fresh. But it seems that Lansbury was buried alive in an extravaganza that kept growing, in the wrong way, through 57 Broadway previews and three directors. Gillian Lynne’s crisp, straightforward new production puts Dear World to rights on the smaller scale it clearly needs, with a cast of 15 always sure of where it’s going, nimbly played orchestrations by Sarah Travis and adaptable if slightly clichéd Parisian set designs by Matt Kinley.
There’s still a touch of initial uncertainly in David Thompson’s new version. The plot – one-third realism to two-thirds fantasy, to reverse a judgment on the original play – could hardly be simpler or more topical. The collective Satan is a board of directors (Peter Land, Jack Rebaldi and Robert Meadmore with Anthony Barclay and Stuart Matthew Price, pictured right) led by a louche prospector who’s discovered oil under the Café Francis in Paris’s Chaillot district and who suggests drilling soon. The angel is Aurelia, with method in her madness and a gathering of loyal if stereotypical friends. “Grassroots advocacy versus fracking,” enthused my NGO companion.
So it would still make for a stronger start if the suits began the show with the scene-setting satirical number “The Spring of Next Year”, transferred in Lynne's production to the second act. It’s a waltz, like so many others here; we’re almost in A Little Night Music territory. Instead we get an Occupation dumb show narrating how the Mute (dancer Ayman Safiah in perhaps the only thankless role) became so. We have to wait until the end to see the point of that.
Buckley’s first number, “A Sensible Woman”, is also weak - one of several extras restored to this adaptation. But already her beatific aristocratic bearing, which belies the oddities of her speech, cries star quality. And soon she’s off spreading light with “Each Tomorrow Morning” and sadness, with a terrific pianissimo start, in “I Don’t Want to Know”. Two more hits follow in Act Two, the simple but ineffably touching reminiscence of lost love “And I Was Beautiful” and the slightly extraneous “Kiss Her Now”. It’s only a pity the titular torchsong of eco-ruin is cut short.
There’s strong support from Paul Nicholas as a far from corny Sewerman – though his Act Two routine, another addition, doesn’t quite work – the superb quartet of capitalists, going through Little Swans dance routines at one stage, and the dispensible but well-sung young lovers (Katy Treharne and Stuart Matthew Price). But while no-one can steal the show from Buckley, Annabel Leventon and the tirelessly inventive Rebecca Lock as her fellow Madwomen from the Flea-Market, vamp Constance who hears voices around the house, and from Montmartre, Gabrielle with her invisible doggie Dickie come close (all three pictured above left). The tea-party trio shot through with Giraudoux’s Lewis Carroll absurdity and ending in effervescent three-part counterpoint is a highlight of this quirky show. Don’t miss it before it makes a major transfer - off-Broadway, perhaps?
Listen to the Tea Party sequence in the original Broadway cast recording
- Dear World at the Charing Cross Theatre until 30 March
- Read David Nice's blog, I'll Think of Something Later
Share this article
Subscribe to theartsdesk.com
Thank you for continuing to read our work on theartsdesk.com. For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 10,000 pieces, we're asking for £2.95 per month or £25 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.
To take an annual subscription now simply click here.
And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a theartsdesk.com gift subscription?
A bit of everything in theartsdesk's stage tips
How to turn an epistolary humour book into a West End play starring James and Jack Fox
Patrick Marber’s adaptation of Turgenev’s classic is fun, but lacks subtlety and profundity
Bryn Terfel's effortless Tevye hampered by amplification as the shtetl musical hits the Proms
The Wilton Diptych meets Monty Python, and Richard II comes to provocative life
Take a ride through 400 years of British theatre with our fictional guides
As the Royal Court introduces some very young playwrights, we celebrate the great child authors
An endearing, old-fashioned family drama featuring real-life parents and their offspring
Off Broadway hit shines in Off West End transfer
Shakespeare filleted but partly fleshed back out by Mendelssohn's lovely music
Nick Payne's revived quantum multiverse romcom is out of this world
Stephen Merchant makes an engaging stage debut