mon 25/09/2017

Against, Almeida Theatre review - Ben Whishaw is a modern-day Jesus | reviews, news & interviews

Against, Almeida Theatre review - Ben Whishaw is a modern-day Jesus

Against, Almeida Theatre review - Ben Whishaw is a modern-day Jesus

New American drama about God and violence is baggy, but often brilliant

Saintly chat: Ben Whishaw and Emma D’Arcy in 'Against'Johan Persson

Luke is a Silicon Valley billionaire, a high-tech wizard. And he’s just had a message from God. And what does God say? Well, He says, “Go where there’s violence.” So what does Luke do? He does what he’s been told, and devotes his considerable intellect and his even more considerable resources to solving the problem of violence in our society. Okay, it sounds wildly implausible, and if Luke wasn’t being played by Ben Whishaw in this new play by the ace American penman Christopher Shinn, at the Almeida Theatre, I might not have believed it either. But he is, and so I do.

Against takes this simple idea, and runs with it. And I mean runs, not jogs, not strolls, but runs. We watch Luke visit the shell-shocked parents of a kid who has committed a school shooting, then a university where there’s been a badly handled case of sexual violence (with a brilliant satire of campus political correctness, complete with an odious professor), then a prison where he encounters the father of a child who has been abused, and then a food-packing business, part of an industrial empire called Equator (run by Jon, an entrepreneur already known to Luke). Scene follows scene in a dizzying sequence. Everywhere he goes, Luke brings his simple message: “Anytime we treat anyone with violence – we do damage to our souls.”

Whishaw conveys immediately the lonely sincerity of a man possessed by a great vision

Luke’s quest to do good is full of great intentions. He wants people to talk more, to express more of what they are feeling, to get at the root of why there is so much viciousness in the world. But everywhere he runs into problems, and everywhere he finds blind alleys. The former best friend of a school shooter feels burdened with guilt because he rejected the boy, who was then lonely and a misfit. Many victims are too traumatised to speak, or to change the way things are. And there are many, many who just want to talk to Luke, who rapidly becomes a Christ-like figure, a magnet to the dispossessed and the needy.

In the first half of a three-hour evening a lot of this is predictable and unsurprising, but the momentum picks up in the second half. Luke gradually appears to be more Jesus-like than ever, not just in his ability to work minor miracles (making a broken watch work again) and to inspire millions (he becomes a mega celebrity), but in his sexlessness. As the play’s love interest, Luke’s collaborator Sheila, points out, “Jesus didn’t fuck.” And the suppressed erotic tension between these two gives the story an emotional undertow, and grounds Whishaw’s performance very much in a classic will-he-won’t-he? mode.

As you’d expect, Whishaw rules the stage. He conveys immediately the lonely sincerity of a man possessed by a great vision, a genius with an idée fixe. As an actor, he exudes a kind of armoured niceness, an aura of sainthood, a careful magnetism that is also a complete closure to intimacy. At certain moments, almost inadvertently, Whishaw raises two fingers in a gesture reminiscent of Byzantine religious paintings. Yes, as he meets the poor and the troubled, the meek and the sinners, he is that close to blessing them. Then, in the second half, you can feel the gradual thaw that comes over his body: he begins to loosen up. This is especially apparent in the scenes when he revisits his childhood home.

AgainstThe beautiful thing about this play is not only its portrait of Luke as a present-day Jesus, but also the tender and tentative way in which it shows how people struggle to connect. It illustrates the emotional blocks, the deep uncertainties and how the weight of the past burdens the present. Whenever any character reaches out, you feel a sudden rush of recognition and of affection. Everyone in the play is hurting, and needy, and most of them know it. It really is very touching.

This is also a play about ideas, and it’s hard to summarize the wealth of cerebration going on here. As well the scathing satire on political correctness in American colleges, Shinn is particularly critical of the kind of contemporary radical thinking that sees violence everywhere, and sees all types of violence (whether physical or verbal) as equivalent. The scenes set on the campus offer plenty of examples of a species of excruciating leftist over-thinking that leads nowhere. At the same time, Luke’s gradual realisation that he is not immune to violence, and that his mission needs to be radically revised, that what is required is a total revolution in behaviour, raises big issues that are probably impossible to resolve.

So Against is not an easy play to like. Apart from Sheila, most of the other characters are just sketched in, and this is very much the gospel according to Luke. The reprise of a satirical scene between a creative writing student and her professor in the second half is unnecessary, and slows things down. And some of the best situations, such as the packing factory with its workers and creepy supervisor (pictured above), almost cry out for a play of their own. Still, there is much to enjoy in Ian Rickson’s sensitive and often delicate production.

On Ultz’s bare wooden flooring with a minimum of props, Whishaw propels the action, and his quiet energy is well supported by the rest of a large ensemble cast. So lots of praise to Amanda Hale (Sheila), Kevin Harvey (Jon/Professor), Emma D’Arcy (student), and the three factory personnel: Elliot Barnes-Worrell, Adelle Leonce and Martin McDougall. Nancy Crane plays four incidental roles. Okay, it’s a bit of a baggy monster of a play, but it has some marvellous moments of wry humour and acute emotional insight. It’s one of the best examples of new writing at present on the London stage.

@AleksSierz

Most of the other characters are just sketched in, and this is very much the gospel according to Luke

rating

Editor Rating: 
4
Average: 4 (1 vote)

Share this article

Add comment

Subscribe to theartsdesk.com

Thank you for continuing to read our work on theartsdesk.com. For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 10,000 pieces, we're asking for £3.95 per month or £30 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.

To take an annual subscription now simply click here.

And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a theartsdesk.com gift subscription?

newsletter

Get a weekly digest of our critical highlights in your inbox each Thursday!

Simply enter your email address in the box below

View previous newsletters