CD: Katherine Jenkins - This Is Christmas | New music reviews, news & interviews
CD: Katherine Jenkins - This Is Christmas
Welsh crossover diva's seasonal offering
Does this disc succeed in doing what it sets out to do? Yes, it does, which makes my minor carpings irrelevant. It’s already selling in industrial quantities. But, to quote a review of another Christmas album on this site, “an album full of tunes you’ve been hearing all your life needs to be adept at reinvention”, and too many of the traditional numbers featured here follow the same template – gloopy, synthetic sounding production values and glacial tempi. Experience has convinced me that carols can be most emotionally potent when they’re sung by untrained, youthful voices. We’ve all welled up watching school nativity plays.
Jenkins’s light mezzo voice never sounds forced, and you wonder how she’d cut it in opera. But she rarely sounds fully engaged. Understandable, given that these tracks were probably recorded on a hot summer’s day. O Come O Come Emmanuel and Away in a Manger exemplify the album’s shortcomings. Both are slow and resolutely earthbound, despite Sally Herbert’s classy backing orchestra, full of A-list orchestral players. But turn to the lighter fare and the mood abruptly lifts. Chestnuts Roasting on an Open Fire is undeniably sweet, and Jenkins even manages to make Santa Baby her own, without eclipsing Eartha Kitt’s original.
John Rutter’s I Wish You Christmas’s schmaltzy harmonies confirm its place as a modern classic, and Sally Herbert’s arrangement of the Wexford Carol will induce a few tingles. The sensitive may wish to avoid the CD's two closing numbers. Come What May has been hyped as a duet with Placido Domingo, though it’s clear that his heavily-accented, vibrato-laden contribution was added afterwards. In a different country, presumably. O Holy Night, pairing Jenkins with Nathan Pacheco, is yet more saccharine. This is not a classical CD, though it's riding high in the classical charts. Jenkins herself would be the last to claim that she's a serious classical artist. And as such, it's fine.
Subscribe to theartsdesk.com
Thank you for continuing to read our work on theartsdesk.com. For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 10,000 pieces, we're asking for £2.95 per month or £25 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.
To take an annual subscription now simply click here.
And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a theartsdesk.com gift subscription?
more New music
Are you hipster and highbrow enough for Metronomy's in-jokey pop?
Music crosses borders in the shadow of war, with Bassekou Kouyaté and Paul Weller
Peculiarly packaged two-volume collection of essential Seventies Nigerian soul-rock
Scottish and English folk ballads are given the ambient drone treatment by the Earth mainman
British space-funk collective blend local and global while keeping rumps shaking
The producer and record label boss delivers a beautiful blend of influences
Yet another frustrating album from the art-punk outfit
A glimpse of what Europe's cosmopolitanism can really mean in Barcelona
From alt-pop to doom metal to Haitian party tunes, all musical life is here
Expect the unexpected on Canadian songwriter's immersive breakup album
This self-declared official 40th anniversary of punk compilation misses the mark
Game-changing US producer embraces the new with mixed results