Bell, LPO, Jurowski, Royal Festival Hall | Classical music reviews, news & interviews
Bell, LPO, Jurowski, Royal Festival Hall
A cabinet of musical curiosities yields some moments of treasure
Despite the best attempts of Stephen Johnson’s programme notes to create synthesis from last night’s London Philharmonic Orchestra concert, there was something rather smash and grab about the programming. It was as though Jurowski, suddenly inspired to play classical Supermarket Sweep, had emerged with a disparate trolley-load of Zemlinsky, Mozart and Szymanowski – oh, and the Brahms Violin Concerto. With a full crowd lured by big-name soloist Joshua Bell, the question was not only what the LPO would make of this disparate collections of curiosities, but also the audience.
The Brahms concerto – the evening’s headline act – was, however, much the most uneven performance of the night, and despite the obligatory cheers and endless bows I was left impressed, but emotionally rather underwhelmed. In Bell’s interpretation it is the Adagio that sets the keynote of the concerto. Although ardent, showcasing Bell’s sweetest tone, this middle movement had a determined intimacy about it; passions were turned inwards, and even in the opening dialogue with the oboe Bell seemed reluctant to reach out. Physical gestures were big, but the sound rarely matched them, and it was only with Bell absent from the texture that Jurowski’s orchestra were able to swell to full force and momentum.
Zemlinsky’s work tends to bombast, leaving one mourning the composer as Hollywood’s greatest loss
The opening Allegro felt as though it already had the Adagio in its sights, negotiating its way stylishly yet always carefully forwards. Pacing was fine, but temperament seemed more at issue. We were never in any danger of being swept off our feet by the sedate waltz theme, and despite Bell’s ubiquitous portamenti and vibrato I didn’t quite believe the tale of Sturm und Drang he spun from the forte theme.
This was Brahms played for spontaneity, for in-the-moment directness, and what it gained in personality (Bell’s own first-movement cadenza is a thing of folksy charm, whimsical little glimpses of the waltz theme caught through a gauzy curtain of harmonics) it lacked in stature and scope. Nowhere was this plainer than in the concerto’s closing three chords; Jurowski drew impressive emphasis from the LPO, but this only served to emphasise the disjunction between these and the tone of the concerto as a whole. Like vast wrought-iron gates at a country cottage the two simply didn’t belong together.
Despite not being the theatrical curtain-raiser critics have named it, Mozart’s miniature Symphony No 32 in G major did a very good job of opening proceedings. Textures here must match the telescoped developmental structure for clarity, and Jurowski’s none-too-chamber band of musicians managed exactly this, firing off the initial scalic theme with the precision of a gun-salute, before segueing directly into the lingering suspensions of the Andante.
What relation this opener had to the Orientalist fantasy of Szymanowski’s Symphony No 3 (I’m not quite convinced by the symphony-in-one-movement argument) or the choral tone-poem that is Zemlinsky’s Psalm 23 I’m not sure, but this post-interval set definitely seemed to be the business end of the concert. The London Philharmonic Choir (particularly the upper voices) made a persuasive case for the more bucolic episodes of the latter work, sitting smoothly on the rather self-consciously verdant pastures summoned by Jurowski’s (pictured above) woodwind and harps. Unfortunately Zemlinsky’s passion rather overtakes him, and the work tends to bombast, leaving one mourning the composer as Hollywood’s greatest loss.
Subscribe to theartsdesk.com
Thank you for continuing to read our work on theartsdesk.com. For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 10,000 pieces, we're asking for £2.95 per month or £25 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.
To take an annual subscription now simply click here.
And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a theartsdesk.com gift subscription?
more Classical music
French modernism, classical piano concertos and a delectable collection of orchestral miniatures
Among the Christmas staples, it's a relief to find an imaginative take on a different theme
Hymning the human in a Nielsen masterpiece and the cosmic in a psychedelic epic by Busoni
Six of 2014's best seasonal releases
French Baroque specialists take musical journey around early 18th-century Europe
An earthbound Messiah lacks wonder and urgency
Christmas music from far and wide glowingly sung by a young, rising, gifted British choir
Dream team for Birtwistle, while the pianist shines in Ligeti and Messiaen
The Hilliards and Garbarek know how to play the building
Birtwistle’s new Piano Concerto dazzles, but that's only one course in an orchestral feast
Tribute showcases a master of both the miniature and the monumental
Russian symphonies, a seasonal ballet and a Norwegian guitarist's debut disc