tue 23/07/2024

The Secret World of Lewis Carroll, BBC Two | reviews, news & interviews

The Secret World of Lewis Carroll, BBC Two

The Secret World of Lewis Carroll, BBC Two

150 years on, Carroll’s surreal, truthful masterpiece under the magnifying glass

Familiar company: John Tenniel's illustration to the tea-party in 'Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland'

Alice is always with us; the most quoted work of literature, after the Bible and Shakespeare. In fact, Desert Island Discs should probably add Alice to the mandatory Bible and Shakespeare as an automatic inclusion for the survival kit.

Now 150 years after the publication of Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland, written by a celibate mathematics don at Christ Church, Oxford, real name Charles Lutwidge Dogdson (pictured, below right), there are translations into countless languages, including that of the Australian aboriginals, who historically did not even have a written language.

In the past few years alone there has been a major exhibition at Tate Liverpool of artists affected by Alice from Salvador Dali to Sigmar Polke, and a three-act ballet for the Royal Opera House by Christopher Wheeldon; another exhibition of books, documents and photographs will open in May at the Museum of Childhood. Not to mention endless biographies of the author, and a published selection of his letters (he wrote, it is estimated, some 98,000 in his lifetime), numerous illustrated editions by different artists, and scholarly studies of all the jokes and allusions readily apparent to the intelligentsia of the time, but obscure in the 21st century.

Rabbits hopped down rabbit holes, Alice illustrations sprung animatedly to life

And now that astute television and radio journalist Martha Kearney, who when a ten-year-old herself played Alice to critical acclaim for the Ditchling Players in Sussex, presents a narrative about the author. Lewis Carroll was the son of a vicar, one of ten children (as a child he devised many an entertainment for his siblings), had a speech impediment, was officially celibate all his life, and evidently and surprisingly (although not explored here) was a dull tutor, although a witty deviser of puzzles, a good amateur artist and a superb photographer.

Kearney gracefully wove together interviews with novelists (Philip Pullman, suggesting his Lara is a direct descendant of Alice; Will Self reminding us you do not have to be a good man to write a great book); and biographers, scholars and relatives, including the great-granddaughter of the child who inspired Alice, and the great-great niece of the author himself. We visited the sites of Oxford and the Thames that framed Carroll’s life and were painlessly introduced to Victorian society of the time, and specifically Carroll’s involvement with the Liddell family at Christ Church.

The Liddell father was the Dean of Christ Church, a position of enormous prestige, and his wife such a snob that she was called the Kingfisher, as she angled for acquaintances with various royals. Their family of six contained three daughters, including Alice, who were warmly befriended by Carroll, and we were shown the very view of the beautiful walled garden of Christ Church belonging to the Deanery, that Carroll had from the college’s library, and from which vantage point he first saw the daughters at play.

 Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland was a tale told to Alice Liddell, notably on a long summer day on the Thames, rowing from Oxford to Godstowe (Kearney, below left, on the river); it was Alice who wanted it written down, and to whom Carroll gave his original manuscript. Now the city of Oxford has an Alice Day on the 4th of July every year to mark the summer on which the tales of Alice were first told.

The real-life story and the fictional world were interwoven in the programme. Rabbits hopped down rabbit holes, Alice illustrations sprung animatedly to life, and there were scenes of serene beauty offered by Christ Church itself. (The college’s dining hall was used indeed for Hogwarts in the Harry Potter films, and someone could not resist saying Alice was, so to speak, the Harry Potter of her day.)

Carroll was a pioneering and passionate photographer, perhaps in more ways than one. He took portrait photographs of the grandees of the day, but it is the scores of images of children which seem so suspicious to us today; we were shown an interesting parallel with that other great amateur, Julia Margaret Cameron, who also photographed the same subjects.

The programme concluded with an examination of his photographs, sometimes turned into coloured illustrations, of naked young girls. We were told this interest was not thought suspect at the time, as sexually immature children were thought to be innocent, while an interest in adolescent children would have set off warning bells. The age of consent, by the way, in the 1860s was 12.

The discovery – perhaps Carroll’s “secret” world – was of a photograph possibly but not proven to be by Carroll of (again, possibly) Lorina, Alice’s older sister, in the collection of the Museum Cantini in Marseilles. The model is naked and definitely already pubescent.

Various suggestions were made as to what we should make of Carroll’s fascination with pre-pubescent girls, and the significance of this newly discovered photograph. The evidence is in fact scant. But there was indeed an unexplained rift with the Liddell family, never to be completely healed, as the daughters reached adolescence. Carroll’s family excised from and destroyed the pages of his extensive diaries anything that might have explained what happened.

But we were reminded that it was a period when children became central figures in Victorian literature, with authors as various as Charles Dickens to Charles Kingsley. Carroll’s Alice was calm, feisty, composed, and full of common sense in a mad world. At its best this gorgeous journey into the English heartland showed us again the wonders of Carroll’s surreal and truthful masterpiece.

Now the city of Oxford has an Alice Day on the 4th of July every year to mark the summer day on which the tales of Alice were first told


Editor Rating: 
Average: 3 (1 vote)

Share this article

Add comment

Subscribe to theartsdesk.com

Thank you for continuing to read our work on theartsdesk.com. For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 15,000 pieces, we're asking for £5 per month or £40 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.

To take a subscription now simply click here.

And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a theartsdesk.com gift subscription?


Get a weekly digest of our critical highlights in your inbox each Thursday!

Simply enter your email address in the box below

View previous newsletters