On Expenses, BBC Four | reviews, news & interviews
On Expenses, BBC Four
On Expenses, BBC Four
Satirical drama about the Commons expenses scandal has Swiftian overtones
Tuesday, 23 February 2010
As one of the opening captions put it, "you couldn't make it up", and this sprightly drama about the House of Commons expenses scandal duly tacked its way skilfully up the channel between satire and slapstick. Concluding correctly that wallowing in moral outrage was not the way to handle a subject whose full ramifications have yet to land on us (and them) with their full crushing force, writer Tony Saint instead deftly depicted the Commons as a kind of Swiftian monstrosity, ludicrous yet malevolent.
Speaker Michael Martin, Labour MP for Glasgow Springburn, was presented as an antediluvian relic of the worst of Old Labour, dredged up from a bottomless well of class resentment and ingrained bigotry. Normal Commons practice would have put a Tory Speaker in to replace the departing Betty Boothroyd, but Martin (played with a deliciously sly touch by Brian Cox) cannily tapped into Labour's primordial mythology to upset the form-book. "So we work the tea-rooms, call in a few favours," he instructed his smirking cabal of co-conspirators, which included such shamelessly barnacled old stagers as Alan Keen (Tim Pigott-Smith) and Stuart Bell (David Calder). "We'll get some senior party men behind us - make this tribal."
His pals backed him to the hilt because of his commitment to defend the rights (real or more often imagined) of MPs at all costs, the higher the better in the case of the latter. Martin, once bedecked in his resplendent new plumage, saw it as his right - in fact, his class-driven duty - to avail himself of every perk and privilege the gilded Westminster fruit machine could spew out. His initial chippiness when a plummy-voiced flunkey inquired as to the identity of his tailor ("I don't have a tailor") was swiftly mellowed by the rich torrent of taxpayer-funded largesse which flowed down the corridors and under his door, barely monitored by the supine Fees Office.
But little did MPs realise that nemesis was approaching in the shape of American journalist Heather Brooke (Anna Maxwell Martin), whose tenacity and indignation when confronted with a wall of supercilious official secrecy ought to be an inspiration to us all, but tragically won't be. Brooke, author of a book about the Freedom of Information Act called Your Right To Know, began trying to chisel out details of MPs' expenses in 2004, though it wasn't until 2008 that she won a High Court decision ordering disclosure. MPs nobly responded by trying to table an amendment to the FoI act which would exempt themselves from it.
"What kind of banana republic am I living in here?" shrieked Brooke on hearing this news. "Why aren't people storming Parliament about this?" An eminently valid question, which many of us ask on a daily basis. But it was Brooke's bitter fate to have the rug whipped out from under her by the Daily Telegraph, who received the priceless leak of a complete breakdown of MPs' unexpurgated expenses and duly held the Dishonourable Members' feet to the fire with sadistic thoroughness. "This fucking story belongs to me!" she raged, leafing impotently through page after broadsheet page of blood-boiling revelations.
Chivvied along by Simon Cellan Jones' nimble direction, On Expenses was sharp, droll and provocative. It's impossible for outsiders to comprehend how the "mother of Parliaments" ever managed to sink so low, but the film seemed to think that greed, complacency and stupidity played prominent roles. There was a wonderful moment when Tim Pigott-Smith, playing Alan Keen about 50 watts dimmer than an energy-saving lightbulb, wailed: "This freedom of information stuff actually applies to us as well?"
Interestingly, the piece portrayed Speaker Martin as being more alive to the career-terminating perils of enforced disclosure than many MPs, but his proposals to begin implementing measures for greater transparency were considered intolerable by the Members. "Can't you see what's coming, or are you just too stupid to care?" he demanded. Apparently the answer was (b). We now see the consequences all too clearly, as our once-great ship of state wallows like a rotting prison hulk on the Thames. Not many tears would be shed if it went down with all hands.
Video of Michael Martin apologising for the expenses scandal:
Add comment
more TV
Blue Lights Series 2, BBC One review - still our best cop show despite a slacker structure
The engaging Belfast cops are less tightly focused this time around
Baby Reindeer, Netflix review - a misery memoir disturbingly presented
Richard Gadd's double traumas are a difficult watch but ultimately inspiring
Anthracite, Netflix review - murderous mysteries in the French Alps
Who can unravel the ghastly secrets of the town of Lévionna?
Ripley, Netflix review - Highsmith's horribly fascinating sociopath adrift in a sea of noir
Its black and white cinematography is striking, but eventually wearying
Scoop, Netflix review - revisiting a Right Royal nightmare
Gripping dramatisation of Newsnight's fateful Prince Andrew interview
RuPaul’s Drag Race UK vs the World Season 2, BBC Three review - fun, friendship and big talents
Worthy and lovable winners (no spoilers) as the best stay the course
This Town, BBC One review - lurid melodrama in Eighties Brummieland
Steven Knight revisits his Midlands roots, with implausible consequences
Passenger, ITV review - who are they trying to kid?
Andrew Buchan's screenwriting debut leads us nowhere
3 Body Problem, Netflix review - life, the universe and everything (and a bit more)
Mind-blowing adaptation of Liu Cixin's novel from the makers of 'Game of Thrones'
Manhunt, Apple TV+ review - all the President's men
Tobias Menzies and Anthony Boyle go head to head in historical crime drama
The Gentlemen, Netflix review - Guy Ritchie's further adventures in Geezerworld
Riotous assembly of toffs, gangsters, travellers, rogues and misfits
Oscars 2024: politics aplenty but few surprises as 'Oppenheimer' dominates
Christopher Nolan biopic wins big in a ceremony defined by a pink-clad Ryan Gosling and Donald Trump seeing red
Comments
...
...
...
...
Where can I buy a DVD of On