tue 15/10/2019

Eliane Radigue/New London Chamber Choir, London Sinfonietta, James Weeks, Spitalfields Music | reviews, news & interviews

Eliane Radigue/New London Chamber Choir, London Sinfonietta, James Weeks, Spitalfields Music

Eliane Radigue/New London Chamber Choir, London Sinfonietta, James Weeks, Spitalfields Music

Drone music pioneer creates a mesmerising new celestial dance

At Spitalfields Church on Monday night, James Weeks and the New London Chamber Choir set about raising our spirits with three early American anthems by William Billings (1746-1800). How vigorous the round Wake Ev'ry Breath felt, as the choir filed in one by one, unleashing the wave upon wave of blessings for the "great Redeemer King" personally upon every row, building up their force with every new entry and uniting at the front to belt it out one last time: "Wake ev'ry breath and ev'ry string!"
Religious fervour was transformed into an initially eyebrow-singeing blast of political agitation in James Weeks's new piece for choir and chamber ensemble, The Freedom of the Earth, based on the words of radical political thinker and Digger Gerard Winstanley. It began with great choral clamor - the sort of sound that might welcome George Osborne at the NUT - but soon calmed itself down into a steady rhythmic insistence. There were clear nods (via the saxophone and guitar of the London Sinfonietta) to Louis Andriessen's seminal political punch-up De Staat, but, despite the odd punctuating flash of interest (the piercing sopranos at the end of part one, for example), it never quite came up to the standard of its Dutch template, mainly because Weeks bottles it, allying the music with the text's increasing disillusionment rather than its call to act.
Those, like me, who were expecting the entry of musical settings of Walt Whitman to inject some Billingsian oomph to proceedings would have been disappointed. Christopher Fox's American Choruses is a frustrating work. One can't hear the Whitman and nor can one read it, on instructions from the composer. Instead, we work with what we're given: four homages. The quality of the choir was shown off in Fox's engagement with Christian Wolff's pass-the-parcel methods of composition (a hocketing of sorts), "Song". And some satisfaction was to be had from the movement dedicated to Cage, "America", in its aleatorically changing repetition. But the listlessness that had set in at the end of the Weeks became terminal with the final part of American Choruses, "Transcription", and its awkwardly shifting, organ-filled cloud of sound.
Though much longer and more superficially paired down than Fox's Minimalist statements, the works of Eliane Radigue (a drone and electronic music pioneer, receiving her first UK retrospective thanks to Sound and Music) that were performed last night at Christ Church Spitalfields were anything but listless, or encouraging of listlessness. There was too much to pay attention to in her carefully layered masses of sound. What water was that trickling (or was it burbling) in the first part of Elemental II (2004)? Where were those high-frequency evaporations coming from? Between the waves of sounding water, air and fire, what was that fuzzy interloper? Night? Earth? So much was being ushered in and taken on in these large sonic waves.
It wasn't just a guess-the-sound process, however. It was a cleansing process. Ears were syringed (only now do I realise my apartment delivers its own rather enjoyable sub-Radigue pastiche at 1am). Received wisdoms were brought back to first principles. I was amazed to feel the scorching fire from Radigue's aural illusion. Sound had been wrenched away from object. Any more intense an impression of heat and I might have had to move back a few rows. But then I would have missed the details of Radigue's modest bows, her maternal kisses, the intensity of the pride in her eyes as she thanked her instrumentalists - how wonderfully far from the egoistical composer she was.
The affect of her music was undeniable and direct. Part one of Elemental II - delivered by the zealously stony-faced trio The Lappetites (pictured above right, with Eliane Radigue), who interacted little (save a few darting looks, which, in the context of no performers, became an oddly compelling spectacle) - was brilliantly disconcerting. This was an elementalism from another planet, the cyber trio a Martian-like reconfiguring of Mother Nature.
Kasper Toeplitz's bravura epic exploration of his eight-stringed bass guitar in part two of Elemental II (2004) heralded a black-as-night rumble. If the Atlantic Ocean could talk, Elemental II would be its first words. Or perhaps they were those of the earth - a missing element from the first part. Either way, Toeplitz spent most of his time nosing around with seabed-dwelling hertz, frequencies that most of the music you will ever hear will never encounter.
The spirituality of drone music is often misattributed to the possibilities of letting yourself go. In fact the transcendence comes from listening more acutely than ever
But beauty, too, made an appearance in Rhodri Davies's world premiere performance of Radigue's Occam I (2011). His journey up the harp, sounding out octaves, fifths and minor seconds with his two bows, unchained the hidden harmonics of these notes, the upper partials, and allowed them to engage in a most mesmerising celestial dance above our heads, a sort of musical aurora borealis, that I almost thought (hoped) might set off the bell tower's fine instruments.
The spirituality of drone music is often misattributed to the possibilities of spacing out and letting yourself go. In fact the transcendence comes from listening more acutely than ever. Only then will you discover those divine melodic apparitions and hallucinatory holocausts that make the likes of Eliane Radigue belong to a truly holy musical order.

Add comment

Subscribe to theartsdesk.com

Thank you for continuing to read our work on theartsdesk.com. For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 10,000 pieces, we're asking for £3.95 per month or £30 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.

To take an annual subscription now simply click here.

And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a theartsdesk.com gift subscription?


Get a weekly digest of our critical highlights in your inbox each Thursday!

Simply enter your email address in the box below

View previous newsletters

Advertising feature


A compulsive, involving, emotionally stirring evening – theatre’s answer to a page-turner.
The Observer, Kate Kellaway


Direct from a sold-out season at Kiln Theatre the five star, hit play, The Son, is now playing at the Duke of York’s Theatre for a strictly limited season.



This final part of Florian Zeller’s trilogy is the most powerful of all.
The Times, Ann Treneman


Written by the internationally acclaimed Florian Zeller (The Father, The Mother), lauded by The Guardian as ‘the most exciting playwright of our time’, The Son is directed by the award-winning Michael Longhurst.


Book by 30 September and get tickets from £15*
with no booking fee.